Q1 2020 Earnings Call
[music].
This time, all participants are in listen only mode.
Later, we'll conduct a question and answer session and instructions will be given at that time.
I would like to turn the call over to Mr. was telling your Roes your financial profile, Sir the floor is yours.
Thank you operator, good morning, everyone and thank you for joining us today first western Financial's first quarter 2020 earnings call.
Joining us from first Western's management team or Scott, why Li Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Julie Core Camp Chief Financial Officer.
We will use a slide presentation as part of our discussion this morning.
We've not done so already please visit the events and presentations page or first Western's Investor Relations web site to download a copy of the presentation.
Before we begin I'd like to remind you. This conference call contains forward looking statements with respect to the future performance and financial condition, a first western financial and involve risks and uncertainties, including the impact of the cobot 19 pandemic.
Various factors could cause actual results to be materially different from any future results expressed or implied by such forward looking statements.
These factors are discussed in the company's FCC filings, which are available on the company's website I would also direct you to read the disclaimers in our earnings release in Investor presentation. The company disclaims any obligation to update any forward looking statements made during the call. Additionally management may refer to non-GAAP measures, which are intended to supplement but not substitute for the most direct.
The comparable GAAP measures the press release available on the website contains the financial and other quantitative information to be discussed today as well as the reconciliation of the GAAP to non-GAAP measures with that I'd like to turn the call over to Scott Scott.
Okay. Thanks, Tony and good morning, everyone. Thanks for dialing in for.
First quarter call.
Given the extraordinary changes in the operating environment brought on by the Cobot 19 pandemic, we want to spend most of our time on the call today, providing an overview of our response discussing the impact we're seeing on our clients and providing some additional disclosures around our loan portfolio.
Well it begin on slide four talking about our operational response.
We've always had a well documented and tested business continuity management plan and many are business functions have the ability to work remotely.
We started advanced planning in January when the threat of covert 19 was beginning to emerge. So we were well prepared when the yeah. When we activated the business continuity plan in early February as the crisis began to accelerate.
We began holding daily meetings of our pandemic response team a cross functional team of senior leaders throughout organization.
We each took responsibility for holding daily meetings, where their client service finance mismanagement communications teams.
To identify issues to be addressed and develop appropriate responses.
At all times, our top priority with protecting the health and safety of our associates and our clients.
We've been able to keep all our offices open and functioning although we moved to an appointment only model for client service to reduce the amount of exposure for both associates and client.
We transitioned approximately 90% of our associates, the working from home without any meaningful impact on our level of productivity.
Throughout the crisis and the transition to a more remote work environment, all or support functions have continued to operate at 100% and we continue to provide an exceptional level of client service.
The robust digital and online banking platform. We built was well prepared to handle increased usage. We saw in March and now in April and it's been instrumental in helping us effectively serve our client needs well, we scaled back in person services.
We've also made a number of adjustments in our benefits programs to support our associates during this crisis.
Includes providing additional paid time off and leave options for any associates personally impacted by cobot 19.
Changing our medical plan include Cobot, 19 testing and treatment at no additional cost associates, and adding telemedicine and behavioral telemedicine services at no cost sure fight through our associates as well.
And we continue to support our communities.
We've entered or sponsorship commitments for all the nonprofits that we support despite the cancellation of their fundraising efforts a events.
In addition to that we'd make over 19 related donations in support of our philanthropic pillars targeting economic development, the arts and the quality.
Moving to slide five I want to talk about client engagement and and support efforts.
First within our trust and investment management business, we had our clients well positioned prior to the crisis emerging due to tackle shifts we've made over the last year the move to more conservative positions.
About 2019, we moved playing allocations to the lower end of their equity targeted equity weightings as equity prices continue to appreciate without underlying fundamental improvements in our opinion.
Then as concerns about coal with 19 started to go in February we reduce those equity holdings, even further by reducing non U.S. allocations and moved claims to higher cash positions.
Finally, we've taken advantage of the extreme market volatility to increase our trading activity in order to maximize our tax loss harvesting performance.
As a result, our clients have been well position throughout this crisis and have outperformed relative to their benchmarks.
Looking at commercial banking operations, we implemented a proactive calling program to reach out to all of our borrowers.
Real time information and assess the impact to covert 19 was having on their businesses.
We then took all the data we gathered to place he's playing into a risk category, which has informed our allowance methodology.
We started the port relief programs in place to support our borrowers.
On a case by case basis, we're providing payment deferrals payment date extensions and or temporary waivers on financial covenants.
As of April 24th we granted 55.8 million in loan deferrals.
In addition.
Although we are not previously an active SB eight lender our team worked very hard to get our processes for participating in the paycheck.
Protection program up and running.
Our initial focus was on helping our existing clients excess funding through the ppb, but our process was officially enough that we had the capacity to begin offering pvp to other companies that weren't previously our clients.
We started.
Being contacted by lots of companies or couldn't get a response or any assistance from their existing bank. So it's turned into a really good opportunity for us to develop new commercial relationships.
Through April 24th we had <unk> hundred 62.8 million in P.P.P. loans approved of which 160.
2.1 have already funded and 41% where new.
Relationships with whom we plan to to build a into strong clients here.
Turning to slide six I want to review some of the notable trends we've seen.
Before the crisis really started to hit we were having a very nice quarter.
We were seeing strong loan and deposit growth, we had 123 million a new loan production, the first quarter, which represents one of our highest quarters ever.
Even with a crisis.
Turning to have more of an impact in March we finished the quarter with an annualized loan growth of 18% and annualize deposit growth of 34 person.
The strong deposit flows are coming from both existing clients and new clients that we added in the first quarter.
As we saw steady expansion at our net interest margin as we began to redeploy the liquidity we built up.
Last year from our strong deposit growth as well as proactively reducing deposit rates with the change in fed rates.
We're very pleased with the performance of the business. Although there were two nonrecurring items that negatively impacted our financial results.
One was a loss and held for sale intangibles of about 550000, which related to decline the fair market valuation of our fill it L.A. fixed income team primarily related to changing market conditions.
The other was a 4 million dollar unrealized net loss that we booked against our mortgage loans held for sale.
The uncertainty of cobot Nineteens impact on the economy caused major disruptions in the mortgage market.
Sharp fed fund in the U.S. treasury rate reductions as well as the capacity liquidity delinquency concerns in the mortgage industry caused the value of mortgage loans and loan servicing to decline rapidly insignificant relative significantly grew up relative to mortgage hedges.
Resulting in about $4 million lost value during the month of March.
Looking at other notable trends unlike what some.
Other banks have reported we have not seen any meaningful change in credit line utilization rates since the crisis started.
So the loan growth, we're showing is not the result of existing clients drawing down on credit lines as a precautionary another measure or loan pipelines slightly down from pre crisis levels, but remains relatively healthy.
We've tightened underwriting standards and are being much more conservative in our loan pools approval and making sure that the Newbuild. We book are very low risk.
We've seen pretty consistent production in our mortgage activity, which at this point is being largely driven by demand for refinancings.
On the next few slides, we want to show some additional detail around our loan portfolio.
On slide seven we show the composition of our loan portfolio.
The largest segment of the portfolio is residential mortgage loans due to the nature of our client base. These loans are made a very strong borrowers and we would expect this portfolio to hold up very well even in an extended risk recession.
Average loan to value on this portfolio is about 64% with the average FICO score of 769, So we're well secured with strong credit worthy borrowers.
The rest of portfolios also well this diversified as of March 31st the mix of loans was 58% commercial and 42% consumer.
Well, we just slightly we show the breakdown of the commercial loans by industry about half the commercial portfolio is a real estate rental at leasing related.
After that the two biggest segments or finance at 16%.
And health care and social assistance at 10%.
We then dropped to a number of smaller industries that each comprised 2% to 4% of the total commercial portfolio, what's very little exposure to the industries that have been hard hit hardest by cobot 19.
On slide nine we show the breakdown of our commercial real estate portfolio by property type.
This is also very well diversified portfolio with the largest segment being office and office condos at 17% of total CRB loans.
Commercial buildings, adding another personal office buildings, adding another 12%.
Well sure hotel restaurant retail energy sector exposure in the next slides, but in other sectors are concerned travel transportation and entertainment we have no exposure.
Again, we have little exposure to these areas have been hit hardest in recent months.
[noise] continuing a slide 10, you can see just how little exposure. We have in these areas. We have about 18 million in energy related loans these loans or not.
Led directly to energy companies, but rather to individuals with business or personal exposure to the end this energy industry.
This is a well secured portfolio with business assets first either trust and investment management assets Collateralizing most of the loans.
We have to three hotel loans totaling about $11 million the largest of these isn't a prominent geographic area and we have strong credit enhancements in the form of multiple sources, a repayment Ana personal guarantee from a strong guarantor.
Finally, we have just six borrowers with restaurant loans and an average industries or an average size loan size of just under $700000, So very little exposure to that industry.
We have minimal unused commitments to either hotel or restaurant borrowers.
So the outstanding balances in these two industries will not be increasing in the near future.
Now I'd like to ask Julie to review, our capital and liquidity positions Julie Thanks, Scott turning to slide 11, we show our capital ratios and note that we're very well capitalized and have more than 750 million in available liquidity sources.
This does not include that TPP liquidity facility, which is another source of liquidity that we plan to tap into true PPP program.
How confident that we had the capital and liquidity that continue to support our clients throughout the duration of this crisis.
And despite the initial impact at the crisis, we continue to create additional value for shareholders and our tangible book value per share increased by approximately 2% during the first quarter and 12.7% from a year ago.
I'll turn the call back over to you Scott.
Thanks, Julie and Julie can walk us through any of our usual financial slides, which are in the back of the deck has requested in the couponing.
Turning to slide 12, I want to talk about our near term outlook.
It goes without saying that the uncertainty around the severity and duration of the crisis makes forecasting beyond the current quarter.
Extremely difficult so for the time being we're just going to provide.
Some of our expectations for the second quarter setting aside for the moment, the Q2 impact of our Simmons Bank, Colorado branch acquisitions.
And are it'd be a P.P.P. activity.
As I said earlier the loan pipeline still relatively healthy. So we should continue to see good organic growth loan growth this quarter.
Our NIM improved from in Q1 from a 3.1% in January to 3.23 person in March.
Absent further rate changes in PPP distortions, we expected to remain at that level in Q2.
Our fee income in Q2 should also normalized without the mark to market mortgage disruption in late March noted earlier.
We put in place some expense control initiatives during the crisis and as a result, we would expect our core non interest income expense to be in the 14 to 14 half million dollar range for the second quarter.
In terms of capital management.
We maintain remained active.
The share repurchase program throughout the first port threat, a portion of the first quarter.
But as the crisis deepen we hope it or purchases and for the time being we expect to remain out of the market. So that we can fully preserve our capital for supporting clients and communities.
We expect the F.B.A.P.P.P. activity to have a significant positive impact on Q2 revenues and earnings as noted above which make carry into Q3.
Finally, we've continued to move forward with our branch purchase assumption agreement with Simmons Bank and it's on track for closing in mid May providing a 14% discount in the deposit premium will pay to the seller.
As a very attractive transaction from our standpoint, it allows us to deepen our presence in our core market in a way that will be immediately accretive to earnings.
Look where three branches and one loan production office in the Denver area. One of the branches isn't a very attractive area that we had been looking previously for possible denovo while opening.
So we'll be retaining that brands.
Oh, well, considering we're consolidating the other three locations into existing first western locations that are close in proximity.
The transaction will provide both banking talent and an attractive commercial client base that we believe will be.
Provide good cross selling opportunities in the future.
With the cost saves generated from the branch consolidation the transaction will be strongly accretive for us between 70% accretive D. P. S. In 2020, and 15% to 16% in 2021, although there will be some onetime deal expenses in Q2.
Without additional scale that we're adding we expect to realize some additional improvement in our operating efficiency ratio.
We've included the rest of my usual slides in the back of the deck here and would be happy to add any additional color need around those items, but at this point, let's open the call up for questions.
Operator, please open up the goal.
Ladies and gentlemen, if you have any questions at this time. Please press Star then one on your thoughts on telephone. If your question has been answered. Thank you Mr. <unk> south them, but can you. Please press the pound key.
Your first question comes from the line. This is true Gordon Mcglasson Stephens. Your line is open.
Good morning.
Morning Gordon.
Scott So I appreciate the commentary on the loan pipeline being a little bit down, but still pretty healthy I guess in terms of capital raise sub debt this quarter, but overall growth this quarter or lower common capital by about 50 basis points you had the branch deal coming online that will leverage capital little bit further.
Yes, how comfortable do you feel continuing to grow at a faster pace just given the current economic outlook.
Well as they said, we're tightening credit standards, and we've tightened pricing and frankly, we're seeing less of the competitive pricing them. We were seeing you know early in the first quarter. So I think some of that will slow down and margins will improve our country due to improved just.
Just based on the you know pandemic.
The results and banks being less aggressive in here I think we've taken up a pretty careful look.
Our forecast for earnings growth in capital from here and what we've always said is that we thought we had adequate capital to get through.
At the end of 2020, and certainly from our numbers today combination of.
These are normal kind of core operations plus the impact of the P. P. P revenues in the impact of the Simmons you know we feel.
Well have plenty of capital to get through.
2020 and into 2021.
Okay. So so outside of being a little bit more tighter on spreads in on credit you don't feel the need to completely pull your foot off the gas to preserve capital at this point.
We don't have any plans to.
To a stop growth or shrink I I would tell you a you know we are being cautious and in in growth you know, it's it's an interesting time, though with.
41% of P.P. would be one at first western west for new clients and those new clients are people that are either referred by clients that are happy here and we're really pleased with the job we did for them or they are people that we've been soliciting that for whatever reason didn't want to go to the trouble of moving they get mad at their current banking.
They move over so I think that this is a kind of an extraordinary opportunity frankly for us to bring in some really great clients and I don't know how much of that is gonna be on the loan side. Initially I mean, obviously the PPP as a starting point, but but certainly you know we've got something like 100.
Treasury management proposals.
Out or in process right now, which.
We've never seen any number remotely like that here, that's what that's a lot of a really great new business activity for us.
Todays call you want to provide on the capital Gordon the only thing I would add is and you saw we completed our $8 million had that raised in the quarter as well. So we do have some cash on hand at lunch is what the bank and.
Rather than actually Guinea Africa estimates and then.
Okay. Good.
As far as the the deposit premium paid on on the branch acquisition I think the slide deck or you may have mentioned your comments that it's going to be a little bit lower is that related to the timing of the deal or is that kind of a new development.
Simmons had 'em, we had agreed at a price so seven.
A percent it's technically 7.06%.
Deposit premium in Simmons was they actually anxious to make sure. We closed on time, so they added a provision or they ask stay at a provision that if we didn't close by I believe was July 31st that we would have to pay 8% and so we said, okay. That's fine, but if we close before June 1st we'll only pay six.
Yeah, and so we managed to get everybody organized to have an early closing and you know I don't want to say, it's 100% guaranteed but we've got all the.
Approvals, we need now and everything processor in place, we should be able to close on may 15th and achieve that approximately 15% deposit Britain savings.
Okay. Good.
I'm curious if you've done a pretty thorough look at the loans, you're bringing over in that portfolio I guess pro forma it's gonna be probably close to 10% of total loans. So I'm wondering if you you've had a chance to dig into some of these <unk> similar to the higher risk exposure deep dive that you've done on your own portfolio.
So I don't want a sound to inefficient here, but I think this isn't time for caution and so we've actually done now three rounds of reviews of these loans. We did at initial a internal and then we hired a a certain third party.
Loan review service that we've used the before that we feel comfortable with needed the first round of.
Kw due diligence with us I want to say late January early February.
Oh it was during the late last year.
And then we did a second round, where we asked a simmons to to.
Look at each loan the local Simmons T. look at each loan in and tell us where they think the credit exposure might be and then and then we just agreed with Simmons yesterday for us to do another deep dive, which we're doing next week with the local team to make sure we really understand where those credits are and that we can.
Make exclusion for the loans that or.
Not expected to perform as well.
Okay, great and just to clarify Julie the the guidance for the expenses that was just pure legacy first western no impact from the branches that's correct.
And I have to think of in three buckets core.
And that Ed and then the PPP, we're kind of think again those three things that for the core business that was the guidance.
Okay, great. Thank you I'll step back.
They scored.
Again, if you would like to ask that question. Please press Star then the number one on your telephone keypad.
Your next question comes from the line, that's Mr. Brady Gailey from KBW. Your line is open to.
Hey, Thanks, good afternoon guys.
I ready.
I wanted to start with a $4 million of.
Value Austin mortgage.
In the last month of quarter in March.
Whereas the flow did that flow through as a as a negative and that the fee income in the mortgage line.
Yes, it it flows through that.
What is essentially the gross.
Hi revenue line, which is actually net revenues net of.
Hedging expense and net of commissions.
So.
So let me just give you a little color on.
On how that worked it 'cause it's its not obvious from the numbers that.
We presented.
So in Q4 of last year, we funded $198 million in mortgage loans in in Q1 of this year, we funded by coincidence, he's actually number, but but that's actually not the number that drives the revenue recognition is it's actually driven off of the luck loans.
Yeah. So in Q4 last year, we like the 161 million and in Q1, we like 463 million.
That's a tripling of lock volume from last quarter to this quarter.
And then the revenues that we reported in the financings that we released last night show 2.6 million in revenues last quarter 2.5 million.
So had we achieved the same margins in Q1 that we achieved in Q4 course revenues would have been something like three times higher and so you can see there the missing $4 million. So let's talk about what happened with a $4 million. So in the latter half of March you remember that we had this.
Emergency tumors as he said meetings they cut rates 100, a 50 basis points. The fed started buying bonds and mortgage backed securities at a very rapid rate very sharp increase rate and then we had the mortgage secondary market fall apart because we had a lot of concern as I mentioned in the prepared comments about.
The value of service, saying liquidity, how deep the market was willing to keep absorbing mortgages and and I had a mortgage is described this is a once in a lifetime decoupling from a the secondary market to the mortgage backed securities that we use as our hedge position when we're hedging against us.
These loans that were locking from the time, we'd like them to the time, we sell so so that's where so you end up on March 31st you have to do a mark to market.
The long position you have in the loans in the short position you have in the hedges, which are mortgage backed securities and you've got this huge.
Credit.
[noise] spread that's good that's gap in the latter half a march and and it's not a record you know its unrecognized for the most part because it's just the mark to market and then you would expect that to normalize and in fact, we can say today 30 days later that that has substantially normalized and.
That you know, we're closing loans today or a booking loans today at.
Margins that were better than they were in the fourth quarter. So.
So that's that's the story there.
So Scott you did two and half million a mortgage fees you had a 4 million back that's six centers.
Uh huh.
Record high for you guys had how do you think.
That will trend for the rest of the year.
So.
Of course, we don't know right a lot of that was a refinancing from the big drop in rates that we saw in the first quarter. So that's already slowed you know our originations in Q in Q2, so far down about 60% in April from what they were in March but.
As they say we've seen a really nice.
Recovery in the margins in fact, they are they're better than they were prior to the whole.
Over disaster.
All right and then looking at the rest of the in Colorado, or they're going to guidance, you're talking about how fee income should normalize.
I'm, just wondering kind of what what you meant by that remark as far as normalizing and then when you look at troughs of investment management, there was pretty flat on a linked quarter basis I mean, it you know what the market.
<unk>.
Well off I know, it's recovered log what the markets often do you think there would be pressure.
On the 4.7 million of revenue as we look for the rest of the here.
Yes so.
I agree with your comments you know what is normal right, who knows but but what I guess I was trying to say there is historically and it's and it's been kind of remarkably crew over the 18 years or whatever it's been at first Western now where we have about 50 50.
Split between revenues that are net interest income and revenues that are non interest income and ER and so I guess, what I was really trying to say there is I think that that's going to move back in that direction. In Q2, a you know we have to being components is a number of components in the fee income, but the two big ones are the.
Planning Trust and investment management fees, yeah. The mortgages. So the mortgage as we kind of already talked about I think that that will be more inline with what we saw and Q2 Q3 of last year, which is you know the bigger bigger season in Colorado and in most of our foot.
Brent.
So that's I think where we would expect things to be there of course, who knows right. We've had a strong April I don't know where may and June are gonna be.
It seems like a we're seeing good good demand going into me on the P. Tim fees.
Most of those fees are calculated on a daily average and so most of the first quarter.
The markets were relatively strong we talked about how we had moved our clients into a more defensive position. So we would expect our client portfolios.
To significantly outperformed for example, the S&P headline this would be 500 equity deadline.
And in fact, they did and then you look at the bounce back we've had and I think that that would be helpful. In Q2 as well.
Since we're working off of a daily averages of because the fees are calculated off.
Okay, great. Thanks for the color guys.
Your next question comes from the line Afras Haberman from our age investments your line is open.
Good morning, Scott Scott how are you going wrong.
Could you just go back over.
Yes, you were talking about sort of tell him restaurant exposure.
If I if I understood you basically we're saying your thought they were pretty deep pocketed.
Yes guarantors.
I would that be the way you would describe it.
Well, we have $11 million an exposure there.
I I can tell you that something like 80% of that is to a single property and borrower and guarantor and Uh huh.
In.
And you know this is a prime project in a great location with a borrower that has multiple sources of repayment and ER and then a strong guarantee a behind it as well so.
You know if this is indeed, the longest deepest recession that we've seen since the great Depression. You know was that hotel is gonna have problems I, maybe but you know in terms of.
You don't I'm feeling comfortable about a hotel loan today I think that that's about as well position as we could be kind of they say I mean that counts for the the.
Yes majority of that $11 million.
I got it okay and.
I got on a little late did you see what's your fees were beyond that.
Oh, which originated and this chapter one as well as a chapter two.
So.
Of course that that's still we still being written but what we know as of a last Friday, we had done 162.5 million Julie.
1 million in loans.
And the total fees there I think are just over $4 million.
And then in P.P. too so far we've done some number like 42 million and I think the fees would be another million or so out of that so pedal I think you know some number in the low fives as looks like where we're headed right now we're still seeing new applications and the program still open hats off to.
Day, but but the volumes drop we down for us.
And did you discuss yet.
In terms of what you're seeing in terms of the bird.
Loans.
Your your thoughts about.
How you can go about.
70, I said in the allowance for June.
Yeah, So we had kind of.
Three initiatives that when when when we became concerned in March about where this was heading from a credit standpoint.
We had all of our relationship folks call all of our borrowers.
And ask them, how they were doing and asked them.
If they needed some additional assistance from us and we guided into either a change in terms if they needed that where we were going to lower their build rates are floating rates are almost all of their floors and so we don't want to lose loans to good clients to competitors and so if we have to drop the floor a little bit.
Or a lower the rate a little bit we'd rather do that they lose the appliance so.
That was the first option second second auction was some kind of a payment extension or deferral and in the third option was to participate in one of these MSP programs, including the.
The paycheck protection plan and so I'm out of that we made a list of.
So called high risk loans, and I don't think they're high risk, but ah ones that we want to pay more attention to and and then we reviewed those with our credit team and the a frontline folks.
Through all that process as of March or April 24th last Friday, we ended up with $55.8 million in loan payment Worksite extension deferrals. So that's about 5% of our portfolio little over 5%, which I think some really.
Good number it's a lot lower number I think than what we're seeing from some of our peer banks.
And and just one well one final question do you want.
Did you touch upon any sort of a real estate related exposure directly land or indirect and that's the final question. Thank you.
We shared on on slide nine of the deck, a breakdown of Oh, the types of properties and the CRB and page eight talks about the loans by the any I see a code.
Too is there any other color you want to add related to.
The the CRB mix or the <unk>.
I think the interesting thing here for me I shouldn't ask to lead to speak and then keep talking but but here we go Oh.
I was thinking about this is kind of primary risk where your lending to a restaurant, yeah, our retail or hotel and secondary risk where your lending to a borrower that has owner occupied see I read that has a restaurant as a tenant in it on the first floor and so we tried to give you information on both of those.
Those by looking through yeah, the loan portfolio composition on page seven then the breakdown by the end SCS code, which you see there very little of direct or primary exposure to these high risk areas and then page nine talks about the breakdown of our see every property types.
And then page 10 talks about the direct and indirect exposure to the stressed industries, which again I mean, you know for energy, it's not your energy loans their loans to.
Well the people that have energy exposure. So that's that's how we broke it down in the presentation Ross.
Any other color I got on them.
I would make it look at it again.
You guys best of luck.
Right.
Other questions today.
I'm showing no additional questions that I would now like to turn the call back to management for closing remarks.
Okay, everybody well thanks, so much for dialing in we really appreciate your interest and your support for first western.
It's interesting times and.
I hope you feel like we're making good progress here, thanks again for dialing in.
This concludes today's conference call. Thank everyone for joining you may now disconnect have a great <unk>.
[music].