Q2 2022 Carvana Co Earnings Call
Hello, and welcome to the Carvana second quarter 2022 earnings conference call.
All participants will be in listen only mode.
Should you need assistance. Please signal a conference specialist by pressing the star key followed by zero.
After todays presentation, there will be an opportunity to ask questions to ask a question you May Press Star then one on a touchtone phone to Australia. A question. Please press Star then two.
Please limit yourself to one question and one follow up.
Please note this event is being recorded.
I would now like to turn the conference over to Mike Levin, Vice President of Investor Relations. Please go ahead.
Thank you I'm Jay good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for joining us on Carvana second quarter 2022 earnings Conference call. Please note that this call will be simultaneously webcast on the Investor Relations section of the company's corporate website at investors Carvana Dot com. The second quarter shareholder letter is also posted on the IR website.
Also we posted a set of supplemental financial tables for Q2 to assist investors in understanding the moving pieces this quarter with the consolidation of ADESA and we've updated our operating plan deck to reflect the addition of ADESA. Both can be found on the events and presentations page of our IR website.
Joining me on the call today are Ernie Garcia, Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Jenkins, Chief Financial Officer before we start I would like to remind you that the following discussion contains forward looking statements within the meaning of the federal securities laws, including but not limited to carvana as market opportunities and future financial results that involve risks and uncertainties that may cause actual.
Results to differ materially from those discussed here a detailed discussion of the material factors that cause actual results to differ from forward looking statements can be found in the risk factors section of <unk>. Most recent Form 10-K and Form 10-Q for the first quarter 2022.
Forward looking statements and risks in this conference call are based on current expectations as of today and Carvana assumes no obligation to update or revise them, whether as a result of new developments or otherwise unless otherwise noted on today's call. All comparisons are on a year over year basis. Our commentary today will include non-GAAP financial measures.
<unk> between GAAP and non-GAAP metrics for our reported results can be found in our shareholder letter issued today, a copy of which can be found on our investor Relations website, and now with that said I'd like to turn the call over to Ernie Garcia Ernie.
Thanks, Mike and thanks, all for joining the call. The second quarter was probably the most dynamic quarter. We've had a carvana we shifted our priorities for the first time in company history to fever efficiency and cash flow in recognition of the changes to the market and the economic landscape as well as to enable us to quickly adjust to changes in our industry that would cause our expenses to be out of balance with sales volumes.
We also complete our acquisition of ADESA and a transaction that we believe will be transformative overtime.
First I want to hit our change in priorities to favor efficiency and cash flow.
We began to make the biggest changes inside the company and make these changes have been significant they've resulted in prioritization shifts across every group in the business. They resulted in the creation of new processes to increase focus and drive progress on these priorities. While it is early in the execution of our plan is going very well so far.
Carvana, we've always set high standards for ourselves and I think it's one of the reasons, we've been pretty successful so far in the long run the ability to keep pressure on ourselves as probably one of the greatest differentiators and how groups of people perform but there is no substitute for the focus motivation provided by market and economic disruption.
Everyone feels and difficulty reveals people what is revealing about people with Carvana is something I already knew and something I can't thank them all enough for the people of Carvana care and they don't shy away from a challenge their fighters the people come on our focus in making faster progress. We have made at any point in our history, they're working hard but they are finding the funding it and theyre making chain.
They're proud of and as a result, we are rolling out new capabilities products and processes at an incredible rate. Our plan is to continue until we reach our goals.
This drove a lot of progress in the quarter in a short period of time, we grew units sequentially by over 10% and reduce total SG&A by 5% at the same time, causing us to drive cash G&A down per unit by $850 in the quarter to $5400.
We set a stretch goal to hit 4000 cash SG&A per unit in the fourth quarter, excluding impacts from ADESA.
Going to be a hard mark to hit but so far we are on the path from there. We will continue our mid term goal of 3000 per unit, we will keep pushing.
We also drove up GPU by $500 in the quarter to $3400. We've provided some bridges back to 4500 and beyond in our shareholder letter the biggest thing separating us from climbing back to that level of execution will be pushing here as well now turning to the ADESA acquisition. We're excited about joining forces with the desk when we completed the deal.
Now that we have begun working with the team. We are more excited first I want to give credit to the ADESA team they've embraced us in a way that we couldnt have reasonably expected their fund group of warn people, who enthusiastic about doing right by their customers and about finding ways to do even better on a personal level. It has been fun to meet so many people inside the company to learn from them and see how interested they are learning from us.
Our alignment is leading to extremely fast progress on integration, we already have over half the cars, we buy from our customers that we plan to sell through the wholesale channel landing at 46 ADESA locations nationwide.
We've already embedded market operations hubs at 18 and Thats the sites.
<unk> is already reconditioning over 500 cars a week in locations that complement our existing IRC footprint, primarily on the coast. In addition, we are also already deepened our relationship with Hertz and ways. We couldnt have without ADESA overtime, we expect ADESA to dramatically increase the scale and customer proximity of our inspection Center network, we expect it to strengthen and simplify our logistics capabilities.
And we expect to find cost savings and revenue opportunities that wouldn't be possible without our combined capabilities. We still have a long way to go to complete our integration and this is another area, where we will continue to push.
Now I'd like to turn to what we're thinking about the near term.
We're going to maintain our current priorities for the foreseeable future to drive efficiencies that we believe serve our short and long term goals best in this environment. While we continue to expect to rapidly gain market share our shifting focus means growth in units and revenue will be slower than it otherwise would be in the short term. We also don't know exactly what to expect from industry level sales in the near term in light of everything going on in the economy.
In July for example, there was another industry wide reduction in demand levels, which has impacted us as well we have meaningful latent demand in several levers to drive growth, which will begin to pull over time, but the speed that we pull those levers will be driven by the progress we're making in our higher priorities.
A more difficult times people tend to get more near sided there are good reasons for this theres value in dialing into important costs fundamentals to get less attention and easier times and as you can see from our priorities. We are focusing more on fundamentals in this environment as well that said, it's still important to maintain awareness of the mountain we're climbing.
If you're a long term lens Q2 has the potential to be one of our greatest quarters. It does serve as a catalyst put more focus on driving efficiency. This was something we were going to do at some point anyway and the environment has provided pressure that we will use to make progress faster than we likely would have otherwise.
Our visibility to much higher volumes with high on the demand side of the equation, we continue to take market share in this environment and the market shares we have in our most mature cohorts provide a clear map to growing volume dramatically. In addition, previous periods of economic strain of accelerated consolidation of our industry on the supply side. The acquisition of a desk is a game changer.
Simply put execution is all this separates us from millions of sales per year from a GPU perspective, our bridge back to 2021 levels are straightforward and from their opportunity remains SG&A has been and remains our biggest opportunity. We have a clear plan that plan is being aggressively executed against with concrete goals in every group of the company.
And we have the historical performance, we've seen in our more mature cohorts as proof points, we remain firmly on the path to achieving our mission of changing the way people buy cars end up becoming the largest most profitable automotive retailer. The March continues mark.
Thank you Ernie and thank you all for joining us today, and we made significant progress in Q2 on many fronts.
We closed our acquisition of ADESA, we set clear operating priorities focused on reducing SG&A expense and driving towards positive free cash flow and we've made significant sequential progress on our key metrics. Despite facing continued macro related pressures and working through internal constraints.
In Q2 retail units sold totaled 117000.
564, an increase of 9%.
We gained significant market share in Q2, despite the impact of high used vehicle prices.
Rising interest rates and other economy wide factors on our industry.
Revenue in Q2 was $3 884 billion an increase of 16%.
Total revenue included $108 million from our acquisition of a desk as wholesale marketplace, which closed on may nine.
Total gross profit per unit in Q2 was $33 68, a decrease of $17 52 year over year, and an increase of $535 sequentially.
Due to the dynamic nature of the current environment, we will focus our more detailed commentary on sequential changes.
Retail GPU was $11 31 in Q2 compared to 808 in Q1, a sequential increase of $323.
Retail gross profit included a $51 per unit impact from earnings 1 million unit milestone gift to Carvana employees and a $34 per unit impact from our may reduction enforce.
Excluding these impacts retail GPU in Q2 was $12 16 compared to 884 in Q1.
Sequential changes in retail GPU were primarily driven by higher spreads between retail sales prices in acquisition prices.
Retail reconditioning and inbound transport costs were similar in Q2 and Q1 as we primarily sold vehicles in Q2 that were reconditioned prior to our cost efficiency initiatives.
Wholesale GPU was $383 in Q2 compared to $219 in Q1, a sequential increase of $164.
Sequential changes in wholesale GPU were primarily driven by a $43 impact from the ADESA wholesale marketplace net of $128 of depreciation and amortization expense as well as increased spreads between wholesale sales prices in acquisition prices.
Other GPU was $18 54 in Q2 compared to 18 <unk> in Q1.
Sequential changes in other GPU were primarily driven by higher customer rates relative to benchmark interest rates, partially offset by wider credit spreads and a change in loan sales channel mix.
Looking towards Q3, we expect to sell loans in the whole loan sales format, but we will maintain flexibility to optimize our channel mix as the quarter progresses.
We made significant progress reducing SG&A per retail units sold in Q2 with SG&A per unit, excluding depreciation and amortization share based compensation and ADESA declining by $942 compared to Q1.
We expect to make continued progress on reducing SG&A expense in the coming quarters as we continue to focus on operating efficiency across all areas of the business.
Adjusted EBITDA margin in Q2 was minus six 2% compared to minus 10, 2% in Q1, an improvement of four percentage points adjusts.
Adjusted EBITDA excludes impacts from earnings gap, the personal stock to Carvana employees as.
As well as other income and expense, which primarily includes changes in the fair value of securities, but it includes non gift share based compensation and expenses related to our may reduction enforced.
Adjusted EBITDA also included a minus $2 million impact from the acquisition of ADESA inclusive of $3 million of one time expenses and the reallocation of $2 million of gross profit generated from Carvana business.
It was internalized following the acquisition.
Following quarter end, we began implementing changes that we expect to positively impact EBITDA contribution from ADESA by approximately $7 million per quarter by later this year.
As a result of the way the teams have come together.
We have continued to learn about the ADESA business the rapid progress.
Progress, we are making an integration and a long term opportunity that exists between our two companies. We are as excited as ever about our acquisition of ADESA.
On June 30, we had approximately $4 $7 billion in total liquidity resources, including $2 7 billion in cash and revolving availability and $2 $1 billion in Unpledged real estate and other assets, including approximately $1 billion of real estate acquired with ADESA.
We also ended the quarter with approximately 1.2 million annual units of inspection and Reconditioning center capacity at full utilization, giving us substantial infrastructure for future growth.
This strong liquidity position, our significant production capacity runway and our clear and focused operating plan positions us well on our path to achieve our goal of driving positive cash flow and becoming the largest and most profitable auto retailer.
Thank you for your attention, we'll now take questions.
We will now begin the question and answer session.
Ask a question you May press Star then one on your Touchtone phone if youre using a speakerphone. Please pick up your handset before pressing the keys.
Is that any time. Your question has been addressed and you would like to withdraw your question. Please press Star then two again please.
Please limit yourself to one question and one follow up you may always return to the queue.
At this time, we will pause momentarily to assemble our roster.
Our first question comes from Zach State of Wells Fargo. Please go ahead.
Hey, good afternoon.
Ernie at the current level of eight to 9000 cars per week shall we view this as a fair characterization of demand for your business today or more so a level that you're intentionally managing to as you shift the focus to profitability and assuming it's the latter.
Can you talk about the level that units need to re step up to in order to achieve that stretch SG&A per unit goal in Q4.
Sure. So let's start with where you are I think.
In the second quarter, we grew units by 9% at a time when the market was probably shrinking by around 15% give or take so when you look at that I think we did continue to take market share. It's certainly at a slower rate than we historically have but but still at a pretty fast rate.
What do you kind of really stop it and taken so I think that that's something to be to be happy with.
In light of the circumstances, we have obviously changed our focus quite a bit and that has real impacts when we think about year over year growth rates a year ago, everyone across every group inside Carvana had their number one priority just driving growth today. Their number one priority is driving efficiency and that has all kinds of impacts we talked about the logistics network.
For example in the shareholder letter that give some examples but there are examples like that everywhere else and so I think theres. There are certainly some impacts that are happening when you think about it from a year over year basis, I think when you look at it sequentially.
There are some impacts there as well are they take the same form in terms of the shift of focus.
We decrease our marketing budget by about 15% quarter over quarter that was certainly from elevated levels in Q1 that we're not interested in sustaining but nonetheless, it's a 15% reduction in marketing spend quarter over quarter that that's going to have something of an impact all else constant.
We've also been purpose about managing inventory down so from peaks and more recently, we probably have around 20% fewer cars that are visible for our customers today than we had recently again all else constant I would put a bit of a headwind on growth.
I think we're making the choice today that we think enable us to drive efficiency as quickly as we possibly can and we think thats. The right thing to do for the business and we're making a lot of progress as a result, and that's that's the way that we're prioritizing things.
I think when we think about kind of what the opportunity is long term I think honestly. It's the exact same way we would have thought about it six months ago or 12 months ago. I don't think theres really anything different we have years and years of history across hundreds of markets of continually gaining market penetration and I think extrapolating off that's not super hard and then even in this environment with a focus change we continue to take market share. So.
I think from a long term perspective, we don't really look at it differently and I think we're certainly you're reducing the speed at which we're growing today given the shift in focus.
Our hope and belief is that by getting more efficient it makes it easier to grow faster in the future because you have kind of less work to do per sale and so we will hope to get that back.
Overtime at some point.
I think when we look to our goals.
We there's kind of two ways that we can make progress toward 4000 cash SG&A.
Axa desktop.
One is just general progress in the business and driving more efficiency and one is certainly getting more units.
So we can you kind of have more units to have our fixed cost blow over.
And I think both are are very powerful.
The first is probably sufficient to get to that goal, it's probably insufficient to get to that goal in the fourth quarter. So without growth that you would probably expect that to push out further in time.
We don't want to I think specifically give thoughts on exactly what we expect growth to be as we head through the next couple of quarters, but I think our expectation of of of stretching to get that $4000, though it does have a gains in both areas, but the primary focus is efficiency throughout the business.
Got it that all makes sense and in terms of your SG&A run rate and in dollars. It looks like the primary step down sequentially was was pretty much all advertising and as you look to Q3 and Q4 can you walk through how how the reduction in force impacts the comp and benefits line and maybe.
Pinpoint specifically, how the SG&A dollar declines should should trend from here and then what the synergies from a desk.
For the for the logistics are our market occupancy lines, how those flow in as well.
Sure so.
I'll hit that one so I think are.
Just as a starting point, we did submit it's pretty meaningful SG&A dollar savings in Q2.
Relative to Q1, I do think those came across multiple buckets, including.
I think our total payroll declined by on the order of $20 million.
Advertising came down by on the order of 20.
$25 million slightly less.
Other SG&A also declined so we did see declines across multiple buckets looking from Q1 to Q2.
That's due to all the things that we've talked about around looking to.
Drive efficiencies certainly the reduction in force impacted the payroll number.
And so but I do think we're seeing gains.
Gains across multiple areas of the business.
One number that stepped up from an SG&A spend perspective was logistics in Q2 relative to Q1, I think a big portion of that step up was related to.
Third party <unk>.
Sports services that we used in Q2 to work to clear certain backlogs out of.
Out of the logistics network in areas that were particularly constrained and so that's something that's an expense that we bore in Q2.
But don't expect to bear to nearly the same degree in Q3.
One particular example, as we're looking out over the rest of the year, we really do see opportunities across all areas of the business to continue to drive SG&A efficiency and so we will be looking we will be looking to do that across the business.
Some of the bigger buckets I do think continuing to match staffing levels to volume I.
I think it would be one of the bigger ones there, but we do see many opportunities overall I'd say, obviously, we're very pleased with our progress on SG&A per unit in Q2, bringing it down by on the order of $1000 quarter over quarter. We're excited about the progress that we hope to make prepared.
The next question comes from Sharon Zackfia William Blair. Please go ahead.
Hi, good afternoon a.
Question on reconditioning, and inbound transport I know it was kind of similar in the second quarter, the first quarter and there's obviously a timing lag here, but you know given the work you've done where is that running now in terms of improvement I'm assuming.
Cars recondition today, and then transported to today is no longer has 600 dollar delta.
Then secondarily I just wanted to as you've shifted focus as a company to costs.
Have you changed the incentive structure within the organization.
Sure I'll try to take those and then feel free to feel free to jump in if you'd like.
So I think first with.
We've kind of Cogs expenses.
We really started to make a lot of these changes in the middle of May and so that's obviously going to take some time to then flow all the way through to sales, which is when we'll see that.
In in retail GPU.
We're making a lot of progress in those underlying expenses just like we are in SG&A and so those those will show up over time, we expect to continue to make progress there.
And then the SG&A kind of flows through immediately as you hit the progress, whereas the Cogs benefit.
You make the progress and then you have kind of a time lag until you sell the car and then it flows through so there there's kind of a is a delay there and again those kind of cost reductions really just started over the last month and a half.
In terms of focus inside the organization and kind of incentive structure I would say in many ways. It's similar it's just the projects that were kind of pulling off the wall are different in their cost focused instead of being growth focus I think we have implemented a number of different processes that were finding really efficient in <unk>.
The company.
Just to dive into too much detail, but across every group in the company. We've got very clear projects. We're doing I think a better job that we have in the past narrowing our focus on those that are most likely to make the biggest impact the fastest.
Every group meeting together on on Monday, and reporting the progress against expectations every single week on Tuesday, where we're getting all of our operational groups together and we go through how each group is performing relative to other groups internally. So we make sure that we can take full advantage of internal benchmarking.
And then obviously a lot of work is happening the rest of the week as well and so I think really it's more about the projects that we're pulling off the board. We've always had a lot of areas that we wanted to work on it was just a question of what we prioritized and so on.
Our priorities have changed but I think we've also implemented some processes that have driven additional focus.
And attention and accountability and speed and.
And I really do think the results of that so far has been pretty great.
Yeah, I think just it's hard to put this in our model, but we have a project that we rolled out for example, the last couple of days.
And just kind of sitting in the room with the team as that was rolled out and there were people across many different offices on a zoom call with 50 people going back and forth talking about the statistics in real time of how this new product was working.
It was it was really cool to see and you can see on everyone's faces. There was just a lot of pride in what they had built that they had built it fast and rolled it out quickly.
And like I said, that's a hard thing to put in our model, but it's probably the most valuable thing over time, because that just compounds over and over again and I do think that.
As we've gone through this change of focus the people inside Carvana have done an unbelievable job embracing that getting excited about it and then pushing very hard and I think that the enthusiasm and speed at which we're getting things done is it's something that I'm extremely excited about and grateful to the team for.
The next question comes from Michael Montana of Evercore ISI. Please go ahead.
Hey, Thanks for taking the question. So first I was just hoping if you could give some incremental color around the consumer in terms of maybe what you're seeing in demand trends for high income versus lower income and then also if there's any impact in terms of credit availability.
And or you know I'm a S piece of the vehicles that you're selling if there's kind of a noteworthy divergence in trend there for high versus low price tag units.
Sure I don't know if we have anything to interesting to share here versus what we've shared in the past or what you might expect but I think in general the trends are as you would expect I think we're seeing.
Higher incomes in general.
They're a little bit better in this environment higher FICO is in general.
They're a little bit better in this environment all else constant that's leading to higher purchase prices, it's leading to.
Differences in MC.
Mix and attach rates for finance and products like that so I mean, I think the impacts that we're seeing are are probably those that you would expect I think you are from a credit perspective across automotive I think in general you. Most finance companies continue to see pretty strong performance I think there has.
Ben.
Slow drift back to more normalized 2019 levels off of kind of what was absolutely exceptional performance.
In 2020 in 2021.
So I don't think Theres anything two notable happening there just yet.
And so yeah I think the only other notable thing is this is a large ticket purchase it's a purchase that is financed its discretionary I think historically it is oftentimes been purchased that leads the economy and then it also kind of uniquely in this environment.
It's driven by kind of the the complexity of Oems Global supply chains. You know this is probably one of the products that has inflated the most in terms of price relative to all other products in the economy and so it's probably an area that is felt relatively more stress. So far are you broadly.
Now that's not great. When you are looking at it in hindsight, but I think when you look at it from a forward lens. It's debatably a good news because it's hard to say exactly what's going to come from the economy here, but if we start from a place of believing that the the kind of auto industry has already taken a deeper stress and the rest of the economy.
I think it means kind of any additional stresses from here and expectation should probably be lessen any recovery from here and expectation should probably be more. So I think you will see how that all unfolds over time, we're certainly in a at a unique time, where it's obviously impacting customers in lots of ways, but as I said I don't think that it's anything unexpected for our customer versus other customers out there.
And then just in terms of pricing just curious if you all have a view that we may see a flat or even decreasing our retail pricing from here and if we do see retail prices decrease into the back half of the year does that make it harder to reach the GPU goals that you've set out or have you already kind of planned for that.
Yeah.
So I think that's hard to say, but I do think let me give you first just a fact I think we have seen depreciation kind of return to the market. So far this year. So that is something that is occurring.
Next is something of a mental model, it's not totally dissimilar from what we just discussed but I think given the car prices have inflated more than other.
Goods and services it is probably likely that on average they will depreciate faster in the future to kind of get back into alignment with.
Their relationship with other goods and services, so I think thats a reasonable expectation.
Whether or not that has an impact on on retail GPU is a little bit less clear than you might think because it's largely a function of what our dealer expectations. Historically, when there's more depreciation you see a bigger spread between wholesale prices in retail prices because our.
Dealers are in effect kind of.
Building in the expected depreciation into the price they pay for card the wholesale market.
To the extent that occur as you could see decreasing prices without.
Noticeably decreasing retail Gpus.
The depreciation is unexpected I think you could see decrease in Gpus, you post that period.
On average you have seen kind of the former you've seen basically a flattish.
Retail Gpus as car prices have decreased.
I do think that in the early depreciation we've seen so far there is evidence that that relationship remains even in our results from this quarter you can see that we began to see higher spreads between the price we paid for cars and the price we were able to receive for cars and so I do think there is some evidence of that spread widening again, obviously thats.
We don't know exactly what will play out, but that's how it's historically played out and there is some evidence is playing out that way now as well.
The next question is from Chris, particularly Arie of Exane BNP Paribas. Please go ahead.
Hey, guys I think you've Gotta beat me to my first question a little bit there.
There, but can.
Can you give us a sense like obviously, the $600 didn't flow through from the logistics in.
And repositioning, but you did see like frankly pretty good improvement sequentially in our retail GPU.
He seemed to highlight market improvements there is that all just kind of.
You said it a second ago on on kind of movements.
Look it's a wholesale pricing or are there other factors that led you to kind of expand that retail GPU $400 sequentially.
Okay.
Sure. So I'll take that one I think we were very pleased with our retail GPU.
Progress in the quarter frankly, I think it was a nice step up once adjusting for a reduction enforce and earnings gift 12, 16 in the quarter meaningful step up from Q1.
And so I think we feel really good about that number in light of the fact that we still have I think that number includes very elevated reconditioning and inbound transport costs and so I think we view that as a real positive I think what were some of the sequential drivers. So one simple one is about $100 of the sequential gain.
We had lost about $100 of shipping revenue per unit in Q1 due to refunds driven by a significant logistics network delays, we basically got that back in the second quarter. So that was part of the sequential bridge.
Second part of the sequential bridge is.
Q4, 2021 was a really.
It really high prime time to be purchasing cars and so as we moved away from Q4 'twenty. One I think that had a positive Mac on retail GPU, where acute in Q1, we were just selling more cars that were purchased in Q4 than we sold in Q2 and Q.
Q4 was a very high priced time to be purchasing so that was a favorable impact going from Q1 to Q2 as well and so I think those are the big the big impacts.
I think.
Yes, I think those were those were the primary impact.
Yes in Q2.
<unk> leaves us feeling in a pretty strong position in light of the opportunities that we still see on the cost side of GPU.
Got you that's really helpful. And then just one related question unrelated question.
If I look at the ADESA financials.
The best I can tell it looks like if I take kind of like the $7 million improvement in kind of like double that quarter to date ADESA financials. It seems like you're probably running 13 million a quarter.
That's a profitability, which maybe a tad below the 100 million you were targeting I know volumes declined sequentially, but so I guess my question is with that long preamble is like is this a good run rate for profitability until volumes improve or is there other reasons to be more positive on kind of profitability ramp in ADESA near term.
Sure. So I think we tried to provide some guidance in our in our in our deck our operating plan deck.
Kind of around $100 million as being a good kind of ballpark estimate for where it is it would be I think we're clearly at a.
A trough.
For for kind of.
The auction business today, it's or I don't want to say necessarily precisely the trough, we're at a low point relative to recent history.
For the auction business for ADESA in 2019, they were at approximately $1 8 million units.
Per year, which is obviously, a very large number there on the order of $1 million.
Shy of that today I think there is plenty of room for the business to continue to improve from here I think a reasonable way to think about how it might improve from here as you kind of look back to 2008 and what occurred back then in 2008 the units dropped by actually a lesser amount because it wasn't really kind of a perfect storm for auctions like the lab.
Couple of years has been and then it took about five years for all the volume to come back as the Oems.
<unk> got their production back up after bankruptcy and everything else.
I think the fundamentals were not as severe the technicals were more severe in the auction business.
Kind of this time around and so I think there is potential that the recovery could be faster, but I think it's hard to know exactly how quickly that will occur I think a good heuristic for thinking about.
What flow through looks like in that business is probably something on the order of $250 of of kind of incremental EBITDA per per unit is probably a reasonable way to think about it and so I think when we look forward. We don't quite know if we're exactly at the at the trough for for auctions, but I think there's lots of reasons to be.
Somewhat optimistic there is there are some indications that Oems are starting to increase their production.
Car prices are starting to dip a little bit, which makes it a little bit less likely that any given.
Franchise dealer is going to keep every kind of off lease car like they have been Oems are starting to sell more cars to rental car companies, which ones of our companies are normally big sellers.
There's room for finance companies to start selling more cars as well so how do we know exactly how that will play out but I think overtime. There is certainly room for volume to continue to come back in and <unk> built a great business with a lot of great customers. So they are well positioned when it does and so I think there's room for it to certainly move materially beyond kind of what are kind of medium term.
Average expectation of $100 million, we put in that deck is so we still think that kind of on average thats, probably a reasonable way to.
To think about what the earnings power of businesses and then obviously there is a ton of things that we're extremely excited about in terms of the way that we're working together our integration really is going very well I know I said it in my.
Prepared remarks, but we closed that transaction, two and a half months ago and we have cars on the ground in 46 locations. We have people that are actively working.
Dropping off retail cars picking up cars were buying from customers out of 18 locations. Those numbers are growing quickly and we've already started to ramp up production in coastal locations.
There's a lot of cost savings there as well when we buy a car from a customer and we're able to drop it off at a nearby ADESA instead of running through our logistics network, we can say pretty material dollars per transaction, there and it also dramatically simplifies our logistics network, there's a ton of gains there I talked about some benefits we've had with some partners, where we've been able to do things that we couldn't have otherwise done so I do.
Do think they just the deeper we get into the ADESA transaction the more excited we get.
Not just about the extremely exciting long term opportunities around reconditioning in logistics, but also around the near term opportunities.
I'll just wait till we can be more efficient together.
And again I do want to give the team credit there, yes, you never know exactly how integration is going to go I think when you do an acquisition that you kind of walk over to the side of the deal closes and you get to meet all the people in and have your first couple of conversations we don't quite know what the reception is going to be and I really will say the ADESA team has just created us with with completely open.
Arms.
And it has been really great and I think the integration has gone a lot better than it might have otherwise because of how open minded they've been and how much they've already been able to teach us. So we remain extremely excited about it we think it's a huge deal in the long term and we also think that there is very big gains we can make in the near term as well, but it's going to require work and we're hard.
Got it.
The next question comes from Adam Jonas of Morgan Stanley . Please go ahead.
Hi, everybody I just had a question about working capital specifically inventory, which of course does declined very substantially about 466 million I believe that number includes the deaths and there is that correct me if I'm wrong.
Is that a level that you feel is is kind of normal that finished the year with it was it do you see it as kind of more correcting from what was this the last couple of quarters of just.
The issues between Covid and in IRC bottlenecks and now Youre at a normal level or is that or is there some kind of making up to do and you need to have like a flow out again in order to achieve the volume that you want.
Yes.
My first question, so I'll take that one so.
We did reduce inventory meaningfully quarter over quarter.
As a note.
That doesn't include any impacts from ADESA, who doesn't have material inventory. So that's just related to carvana.
The main way to think about that is we talked a bit about this on the Q1 call, but we did meaningfully overbuild in various areas of the business.
Kind of moving into Q1 of this year that include an infrastructure that included staffing that also included inventory. So we definitely have been added above normalized level of inventory and so we've been sort of steadily marching it down like over the course of Q2 and also.
So far in Q3, I think we do expect to continue to.
Lower inventory balance here in the third quarter.
Just as we sort of normalize the size of inventory.
Okay to get to our target level and sort of think of our target level as somewhere in the $2 billion to $2 $5 billion range.
And I think I.
I think we'll continue we were above that at the end of Q2, and so I do think we will continue to lower that just to get inventory size in line with.
In line with our targets.
Aligned with the rest of the business and so I think Thats one point.
I do think we've got lots of opportunities to get more out of our inventory.
As we move away from third party reconditioning.
The third party reconditioning typically has much longer cycle times, and first party reconditioning and so as we move away from third party reconditioning that all have a positive impact on.
Recon cycle time, many of our cost initiatives are also speed initiatives.
That have the.
The goals of speeding up the number of days between when we acquire a car and get a DRC speeding up the number of days between when we.
Start inspect the car and get it fully recondition and so we do think we've got a number of leather levels to get more out of our inventory as it normalizes.
All right that's very clear just a follow up then a housekeeping how many cars did you have in inventory at the end of Q2 in terms of units and how that compare to <unk>.
Thanks.
Sure so.
The.
So we don't report that number specifically, but.
But we did see a unit decline in inventory as well that was think of it as approximately in line with the balance decline.
The next question comes from Nick Jones with JMP Securities. Please go ahead.
Hi, Thanks for taking the questions I guess, two if I could on the time buffers in certain states related to title and registration.
Is that a structural I heard all of that is going to persist can you drive more efficiency, there and kind of.
Get rid of that over time, and how do you expect that to impact I guess conversion in those states and then the second question. You know there was a bullet about not passing through the cost of fund increases how should we think about I guess.
When you might start passing that through.
Yeah.
Sure those are two big questions Ellen themselves to long answers. So we'll try to try to be as concise and began.
So first on the time buffers I do you think that's been associated with just ensuring that we're delivering the cleanest fastest.
<unk> to our customers on the registration front that we possibly can.
I'm going to kind of jump into just an explanation on that as well for a moment as I can imagine that's a question people on the call may have.
We definitely are unfortunately got a lot of attention for Reg.
Registration over the last maybe three to six months.
And I think unfortunately that narrative is.
Probably both pretty exaggerated and then also lagging.
Kind of lagging where reality is so I think I want to talk a little bit about kind of the progress. We've made there. So today, we probably have about one third the rate of customers that are getting delayed plates that we had even a year ago that puts us at that kind of the best levels, we've ever been in our company history.
And while it's unfortunately kind of hard to get really clear data around how other dealers perform.
In Heaven registration that is an imperfect process.
Across the entire industry. Unfortunately, I think over time, it's something that many states want to improve but it is a complicated process and so we do our best to try to pull down what data. We can look at various parts of the flow, whether it's title processes or or registration processes and it is the case that in the majority of states we are.
We're performing better than the majority of dealers.
And so I think that's something that we're generally pretty proud of and we think we're especially proud of that in light of the fact that in order to give our customers a seven day return policy in a nationwide inventory. We also have to take on more complicated underlying registration tasks and when you control for the complexity of that were sort of better again.
Then most dealers out there. So I think again the team has done a great job I think the way that we're executing today is better than we've ever executed in the past and it's a level that we're proud of but.
But certainly not satisfied with we're going to continue to push and we've got.
I'm out of improvements in process, a lot of additional improvements and product that we're rolling out to make sure that we're getting all the paperwork that we need to from customers that it's clear to customers what to upload and what to have ready at the time of delivery et cetera, and so we're working on all those process and I think continually getting better.
All the time, we're also working to improve the system, we're working with several states as partners. We view the states as partners in many states view us as partners as well.
Many of these states have registration modernization initiatives underway.
And so we proactively worked with them on those.
We've been part of Legislative change a number of states. We've seen policy changes in a number of other states as a result of our <unk>.
Involvement and so I do think this is something that's actually continually.
Improving and I do think its something where we do expect those buffers to go away over time. So we think it's hard to predict exactly when we'll be pulling those back but the expectation is absolutely that we will pull those back overtime.
And then certainly that does impact sales conversion there. There's no question that faster delivery times impact sales conversion and when we add these time buffers the form it takes to customers as they see a longer delivery time, and so that does impact conversion and we expect to continue make progress there.
Overtime.
On the interest rate changes, what I would say.
We have passed through some industry changes over the last year.
Many months.
If we go back to when as rates started to increase in the back half of last year.
But in general women as rates start to increase we tend to see finance companies ourselves included pass through those increases and benchmarks or risk spreads a little more slowly than they show up and I think that's where kind of the term interest rates are sticky comes from.
And so the sum of interest rates interest rate increases both benchmarks and risk spreads has not yet been passed all the way to consumers I think it's hard to say exactly what will be the smart.
Right for that to be pass through overtime in many ways. It's a function of what other finance companies are doing.
We obviously not perfect data on what other finance companies are doing but we do have pretty.
Good data there and so when we kind of monitor many different kind of larger banks and financial institutions. We've.
We've seen a lot of those institutions start to raise interest rates.
Really starting in March and April kind of a couple of months. After we did and we tend to see them over the last several months raising interest rates by something between 25, and 50 basis points give or take.
Month, which actually can make a pretty big difference pretty fast. So we don't know exactly how other finance companies are going to react we'll continue to monitor.
Disease and try to make smart decisions about how we're handling.
And as rates on our side, but certainly we've seen an increase in benchmarks and spread that has not been passed all the way through and then we try to provide some math.
To make it straightforward for for investors to understand what the impact of that is holding all else constant and we're obviously hopeful that over time that that comes back.
The next question is from Seth Basham of Wedbush Securities. Please go ahead.
Thanks, a lot and good evening and thanks for all the great information I have a follow up question. After the last question that was asked first as it relates to the titling registration challenges are there any states, where you are not able to currently sell vehicles because of those challenges and secondly.
Are there any issues currently with selling.
Selling vehicles that don't have clean titles.
Sure. So there are no states, where we're not able to sell vehicles today.
And no issues with the clean title issue as well I do think over time. These things can periodically pop up we recently, Illinois pop up.
We're we were excited to have.
A judge kind of give a time to make sure that we were able to work with the state and make sure we can resolve.
Some of the maybe.
Miscommunication disagreements that we've had and so we look forward to working with them we share the same goals that they've got the regulators in all these states just want to make sure that customers get the best registration process, they possibly can and that's the goal that we share. So we look forward to working with them and our hope is that we can partner with them in the same way that we partner with many other regulators and many others.
<unk>.
I also say that as <unk>.
That's something that.
Sometimes good things can come out of a more difficult situation, but something that is great. It came out of Illinois. When we were shut down for a period of time there.
As we were kind of working to resolve some of these misunderstandings with the state.
We did reach out to customers and ask for support in 48 hours, we had 6000 customers.
You signed a petition to support we had thousands of comments the team in supporting Carvana. Since then we've had thousands more come in as well and so I think that was a powerful.
Kind of a message from our customers that it certainly customers across the country and in the state of Illinois, and all other states as well are really.
Loving the Carvana experience and those are people that are intimately familiar with our process that kind of instantly came to our aid there, which I think was a great sign and so I think periodically over time Theres. There are certainly risks that will run into these.
With the state here and there but.
In general we've got a great relationship across states and we view the states as partners and our goal is to make sure. We continue to evolve all those relationships. So that we can view all of the states as partners, making the U S. The same way.
Great and as a follow up on the financing business can you talk about the channel mix shift for selling your finance receivables in the second quarter, how much did you sell to ally, what's the remaining availability with that agreement and then.
Your decision to potentially sell whole loans in the third quarter whats driving that.
Sure. So what I would say is I think whenever we thought about.
Where we're going to sell our receivables were trying to balance maximizing proceeds and minimizing kind of cross time volatility I think that's always been our goal has been the reason we've set set up kind of a platform that enabled us to move in both directions.
And obviously there is.
There's been a lot of a lot more noise I think across financial markets over the last many months than there has been in quite some time and so I think.
A form that basically takes is that increases volatility.
In in a process like a securitization and so what we elected to do is kind of in this environment I think we're kind of leaning more on the direction of reduced volatility and we are in the direction of maximize proceeds and we elected to.
Work with allied to purchase more of our loans.
Which is something that we did in COVID-19 as well with very similar motivations and I think that Thats a relationship that we feel has worked out great for Austin and that we hope and believe they believes worked out great for them as well. So I think that's the way that we generally think about it.
We made sure that we always have access to all the different channels and we're monitoring what our expectations would be in each channel again in both of those dimensions, both expectation and.
Kind of volatility around that expectation I think as we head through the rest of the year, it's hard to know exactly.
Where things are going to go it is a pretty dynamic kind of macroeconomic backdrop in these markets can be sensitive to.
You know the way the data flows in across that backdrop, I think several weeks ago. The ABS markets were in rough shape I think the last couple of weeks has actually been very good in the ABS market. So we will continue to monitor those markets.
And try to make the best decisions that we possibly can but our baseline expectation today is to continue to lean more in the direction a pooled loan sales, but again, we weren't sure that we have flexibility to exercise.
Freedom, We think is the right choice to make as we move through the rest of the year.
And then on the question about capacity.
Our agreement with ally was most recently Upsized in March it has $3 2 billion of capacity.
Remaining.
The next question comes from Rajat Gupta with JP Morgan. Please go ahead.
Great. Thanks for taking the questions.
For all the color provided on the call so far.
I just had a follow up on one of your questions on SG&A.
So what happens when you get to the $4000 target no one of them one of the questions. We get a lot in trying to address is.
Once you get to the 4000.
That even further.
How should we think about growth.
Particularly in the context of narrow some video AD spending recently you know some of the other growth initiatives that you've had that you're you know can bring recently.
What kind of like what's the growth algorithm.
Once you get to that.
Okay.
Okay.
Sure. So I think the short answer on what do we do want to get to $4000 as we keep going.
I think it is kind of the plan. So you'll first let's let's talk about the walk from from where we are at $4000.
Is that the level that we've hit many times before in the company's history, and so I don't think in our minds at least Theres, a big question about whether or not we can get $4000. I think the question is how quickly can we responsibly get to $4000. We do have hundreds of locations in many functions across those locations. So there's many hundreds of groups that we have to manage.
Across the business.
And we have to make sure that we're managing our expenses down at a rate that is both fast because we want to get it out as quickly as we can but also it doesn't derail.
These different groups in different locations and different functional areas.
Because thats costly as well and so I think the goal the stretch goal of 4000 at the end of this year is basically more a function of the pace at which we think we can responsibly get there.
Then a question about whether or not we believe that we can get there I think as we look from 4000 down to kind of the midterm goal of 3000 and beyond that to our long term model I think it's just about driving additional efficiencies.
We have many ways to look at where those efficiencies are I think.
<unk> the easiest.
So just look at our cohorts we've provided some data in the past about.
What our SG&A expenses are in some of our more mature cohorts and so I think that provides visibility into what we've been able to do and we were able to do that before we really put focus on you.
Youll prioritizing processes and end products that make us more efficient so we kind of move through this period, where we've prioritized those process improvements.
<unk> and product enhancements.
They were positioning ourselves better to outperform that than ever before we think across every group inside the company. We now have concrete goals that build up to our midterm goal of $3000 per unit I think we've always had bottoms up models to inform.
Our long term financial model.
But now that converting into actual kind of products and projects that we have across all the different teams to.
To get up there and then in terms of what it means for growth I think.
The biggest impact to growth or are probably based on the kind of shift in focus and just a question of which projects before ties in and where we put our effort across the business and so.
I think you know as we get to lower and lower SG&A levels I think the impacts there to growth in our expectation at least are probably positive and again I think the simplest way to think about that or at least the way. We think about that is that the amount of work it takes to increase.
Sales by any given them out is in many ways kind of proportionate to your expenses per unit because they kind of represent the work that's being done inside the company to sell a unit and as we drive those expenses down. It means there is less work to do per unit. It means with the same amount of work we can grow units by more.
So I think we're excited about what kind of these efficiency goals are going to mean for our growth in kind of the medium term.
But I think as I said, we're really focused on gaining efficiency today and I think we're making a lot of progress we undoubtedly have a lot more progress to make and the team recognizes that and is extremely focused.
But we're on a very good path and we're excited about it.
Got it.
Just a follow up on the SG&A.
Within the comp and benefits line is that we you know that you can dissect for us.
What would the corporate employee costs are worsening.
Some of them more.
Personnel related expenses in terms of employees who are involved in.
Actual body, so no financing part of the transaction.
Any metrics you can share around that we shouldn't see that you know.
Transaction time per sale or.
<unk> core sales or something of that sort.
But where are we today and where where do you expect you will get to you know.
As you get to you.
<unk> thousand or <unk>.
7500 target next year.
Sure I can hit the argument that one in a couple of different ways.
Think we've.
<unk>.
And for example, you can see.
What we've achieved in the past is on sort of compensation and benefits for retail units sold I think that's a useful benchmark for where it can go I think we've laid out midterm goals that are available on the.
Investor Relations website that also give a sense of where it can go.
But sort of beyond what we've already achieved in the past I think.
And so I think those are hopefully helpful. Helpful resources for you on that question I think in terms of what we're seeing from an efficiency perspective, we're absolutely seeing efficiency gains throughout the business I think.
Our teams are working.
Every day on those efficiency gains and I think we're seeing things like hours per delivery is coming down.
And sort of.
Customer care.
Phone time per sale is coming down those are a few examples.
Utilization in our logistics network is going up there is and there are many many more that just a few but I do think we're seeing very positive trends in some of these efficiency metrics that we've been focused on over the last.
Several weeks.
Or slightly longer and so I think some of those.
Internal metrics that all of the teams are focused on we're feeling really good about the way. They are those are trending.
The next question comes from Colin Sebastian of Baird. Please go ahead.
Hi, Thanks, Good afternoon, guys. Thanks for squeezing me in.
I guess I was going to ask about sort of the whole process of managing the process improvements, but I think that maybe take a little it takes a little too long to answer here.
So instead as follow ups I guess first off.
What in terms of not using the ABS market is that factored into the GP or what's the impact on other GPU.
If you do not access the ABS market and then and then secondly.
In terms of widening the scope of inventory to capture more value priced cars.
If that if you are doing that are you seeing more demand.
Through the mass markets part of the funnel is that something that you're marketing against or does that sort of that traffic sort of naturally come to the website and the app how does that work. Thank you.
Sure so.
I think on the first question so the way we've always.
Thought about this is we have a two channel strategy for monetizing our loans.
Use the securitization market.
And then we sell loans through whole loan sales or for a forward flow agreement.
And I think the way, we think about that too is channel strategy as it balances economics and stability.
What I mean by that is you know typically in the securitization market.
You see better monetization, but.
But the securitization market involves more variability and so the forward flow and whole loan sales typically have lower monetization, but add a degree of stability. So that's basically the way we thought about it.
In terms of our forward looking expectations I think we plan around expectations.
Four.
Or four four flower whole loan sales as we laid out in Q3.
Our current expectation is we will be selling loans at a whole loan sale format.
We will continue to evaluate as the quarter progresses.
And then I think there is certainly demand for lower price cars I think.
That's definitely something that is true there is basically just a dearth of lower price cars.
Youre out there industry wide today is also true that debt.
Those that are seeking higher price cars are probably less impacted by the economy at least so far.
The form that this thing has taken so far so.
In terms of like demand across cars, it's I would say, it's shifted to cheaper cars less than you might expect.
In light of kind of the desirability of those inexpensive cars, but then also kind.
The relative strength of the higher.
Income consumer, which offset that to a degree.
But I think we're continuing to push in that direction. We've got a number of initiatives to make sure that we're able to provide our customers with a diverse set of cars.
Their needs across all different dimensions of matter, including price.
And working on different product enhancements to <unk>.
Make it easier for customers to afford cars in this difficult environment when when prices are high.
So I think that's an area that we'll continue to get focus from us.
And it's an area, where we've made progress so far and plan to make more progress going forward.
The last question will come from Brian Nagel of Oppenheimer. Please go ahead.
Hi, good afternoon.
We're just running down there so I'll just ask one quick one.
I guess, one question with two parts, but with regard to a desktop.
Oh boy, there's a lot there's been chatter out there about you know now that carvana on ADESA, maybe something stork customers or partners with the desk. So we don't want to do business with us because they're now competitors to carvana. So the question I have is are you seeing that dynamic. If so is that factored into kind of the parameters you've given us for.
The ADESA business.
Secondly, just as we think about ADESA its enhancement to be overall carvana model, what point or how at what point would probably be that breakout moment, when we really start to see the true.
The benefits of Destiny Brilinta Carvana.
Sure ill try to answer those two sites because as you said we are tight on time I think for sure we saw some.
Some customers other deaths initially react negatively to the news and we do feel like we lost.
You have some volume as a result of that.
Immediately as the transaction was announced.
I do think since then the news is actually pretty good you know obviously, we all know how this will play out over time, but we've seen a number of.
Those customers already come back we've seen some big commercial accounts start to shift more business back to a desktop.
And so I think that so far at least it feels like the team at ADESA has done a good job.
Weathering, the turbulence that transaction, which obviously causes everyone had to stop and reevaluate for a moment, but it feels like we're in a pretty good spot and then I do think looking forward, it's hard to know how that's going to unfold again.
This was approximately 1 million units.
<unk> of where it wasn't in 2019, so theres a lot of room for volume increases from here.
Regardless of the number of customers that come back, but we'll be we'll be fighting and shooting to provide great experiences to all this oracle customers of ADESA and Youre trying to explain why we think that is still a great option for them and as I said I think so far the news there is.
Is pretty good I think in terms of when you see when you would expect to see the benefits of ADESA.
I think hopefully it.
Relatively quick we're already seeing operationally some benefits today that are pretty material.
And hopefully it's kind of continue over time and continually increasing and hopefully continue increasing for a long time I think that.
There are many areas to reduce cost there are many areas to drive revenue. There are many areas to collaborate on solutions for our shared customers that they kind of benefit from our share capabilities and then theres, obviously, a lot of room to recondition more cars closer to our customers and to enhance our logistics network to get cars to customers faster.
And I think unlocking all of that is a many many year plan that we're excited about running out as quickly as we can and we're excited to do it with the team at ADESA.
This concludes our question and answer session I would like to turn the conference back over to management for any closing remarks.
Perfect all right well, thank everyone for joining the call to everyone inside Carvana and ADESA.
Thank you so much for everything that you guys have done the last several months has been dynamic I believe was the word that we use in the prepared remarks.
Has felt that <unk> seen that and I think that youll people always have to decide how they respond.
Any kind of adversity, and I think the way that people inside Carvana have responded has been unbelievable I think we could not ask for more we couldnt be prouder to be working side by side with you guys. The progress that we're making is exceptional I hope you're proud of what Youre doing if we keep our heads down we're going to continue to make a lot of progress really quickly.
And that has been awesome to see and is exciting for the future and then for the ADESA team. We've done. This a couple of times now, but I really do just feel extremely grateful.
You have embraced us and the way that you have and I think that hopefully we're both seeing the gains from that.
I think it's showing up in the results already and we're excited about where we can go from here. So we look forward to continuing to work with you.
Thanks, everyone, we'll talk to you next time.
The conference has now concluded. Thank you for attending today's presentation you may now disconnect.