Q4 2024 Real Matters Inc Earnings Call
Speaker Change: Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Real Matters Q4 and Fiscal 2024 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participant lines are in a listen-only mode.
Speaker Change: Following the presentation, we will conduct a question and answer session. And if at any time during this call you require immediate assistance, please press star zero for the operator. Also note that this call is being recorded on those late November 25th, 21st, 2024.
Speaker Change: At this time, I would like to turn the conference over to Lyne Beauregard. Please go ahead.
Speaker Change: Thank you, Operator, and good morning, everyone. Welcome to RealMatters Financial Results Conference call for the fourth quarter and fiscal year ended September 30, 2024. With me today are RealMatters Chief Executive Officer Brian Lang and Chief Financial Officer Rodrigo Pinto.
Speaker Change: This morning before market open, we issued a news release announcing our results for the three months and fiscal year ended September 30th, 2024. The release, accompanying slide presentation, as well as the financial statements and MD&A are posted in the investors section of our website at realmatters.com.
Speaker Change: During the call, we may make certain forward-looking statements which reflect the current expectations of management with respect to our business and the industry in which we operate. However, there are a number of risks, uncertainties, and other factors that could cause our results to differ materially from our expectations.
Speaker Change: Please see the slide entitled Cautionary Note regarding forward-looking information in the accompanying slide presentation for more detail.
Speaker Change: You can also find additional information about these risks in the risk factors section of the company's annual information form for the year ended September 30, 2023, which is available on CDAR Plus.
Speaker Change: and in the Investor Relations section of our website. As a reminder, we refer to non-GAAP measures in our slide presentation, including net revenue, net revenue margins, adjusted net income, adjusted net income or loss,
Speaker Change: per diluted share, adjusted EBITDA, and adjusted EBITDA margin. Non-GAP measures are described in our MD&A for the three months and fiscal year ended September 30, 2024, where you will also find reconciliations to the nearest IFRS measures. With that, I'll now turn the call over to Brian.
Brian Lang: Thank you, Lyne. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us on the call today.
Brian Lang: In fiscal 2024, we delivered consolidated adjusted EBITDA of $1.9 million, moving the business back into positive territory as we continue to prudently manage our cost base through the year to align with the variability in mortgage origination volumes.
Brian Lang: We executed our strategy effectively, adding 16 new clients, increasing market share with our clients across all three segments, enhancing our net revenue margins, and maintaining a disciplined approach to managing operating expenses.
Brian Lang: We demonstrated our ability to scale with volumes, and our financial performance showed how relative changes in the rate environment can translate into improved margins and profitability.
Brian Lang: We remain confident about the size of the opportunity that the U.S. mortgage origination market represents and that there is considerable upside for our business from here as pent-up demand continues to build.
Brian Lang: Homeowners will continue to look for sources of liquidity to finance life events, as well as opportunities to lower their cost of borrowing.
Brian Lang: New household formation will also persist as younger generations pursue the ambition of home ownership as a source of financial stability.
Brian Lang: Today, there are more than 8 million outstanding mortgages with an interest rate above 6%. And the inventory of mortgages being written at higher rates continues to climb daily, growing the pool of potential future refinance candidates.
Brian Lang: To put this into context, $8 million mortgages is double the size of the entire market in 2023, which included purchase and refinance transactions.
Brian Lang: and that pool of mortgages grew by nearly 50% in the last 12 months alone.
Brian Lang: When we conducted our annual consumer mortgage survey this year, we found that 60% of consumers plan to refinance in the next two years and 40% of future buyers plan to purchase a home when rates decline.
Brian Lang: These tailwinds, coupled with our market-leading position and available capacity, position us well for growth.
Brian Lang: We continue to maintain a readiness posture underpinned by our ability to scale and pivot, which will allow us to capitalize on these opportunities.
Brian Lang: We reported consolidated revenues of $172.7 million in fiscal 2024, up 5% year-over-year as a result of market share increases with our clients and new client launches in all three segments.
Brian Lang: Consolidated net revenue was up 8% year over year to 46.4 million dollars and we delivered positive adjusted EBITDA of 1.9 million dollars up from a loss of 2.4 million dollars in fiscal 2023.
Brian Lang: In U.S. appraisal, revenue increased 8% from fiscal 2023 to $130.7 million, led by increases in origination and home equity volumes.
Brian Lang: We also posted year-over-year market share increases with three of our top U.S. appraisal clients, and we maintained our top position on lender scorecards.
Brian Lang: Our net revenue margins increased by 20 basis points from fiscal 2023 to 27.6% which is at the high end of our target operating model and net revenue increased 9% year-over-year to 36.1 million dollars.
Brian Lang: With the increase in volumes on our platform and relatively flat operating expenses, we continue to see strong operating leverage in the business and increased our U.S. appraisal adjusted EBITDA by 18% year-over-year to $16.7 million, which represents an 87 percent conversion from net revenue to adjusted EBITDA.
Thank you for joining us. Thank you.
Brian Lang: as a result of a decline in home equity and REO volumes. However, refinance origination revenues were up 9% year-over-year due to market share increases with our clients and new client volumes.
Brian Lang: With the change in our revenue mix, net revenue margins were up 570 basis points year-over-year, and net revenue was up 3% to $4 million.
Brian Lang: We reduced operating expenses by 11% from fiscal 2023, and we posted an adjusted EBITDA loss of $6.8 million in U.S. title compared with a loss of $8.3 million in the prior year.
Brian Lang: We launched seven new title clients and one new channel in fiscal 2024. We also increased market share with our Tier 1 client.
Brian Lang: On the sales front, we are having productive meetings with our clients, which reinforces our confidence in the ongoing progression of our pipeline.
Brian Lang: The movement in interest rates has revitalized the RFP process and brought growth back to the forefront of our discussions.
Brian Lang: It is clear to us that lenders are preparing for increased volume.
Brian Lang: Lenders are anticipating a potential decrease in rates and an uptick in refinance volumes in 2025 and we are well positioned to scale up and capture that volume.
Brian Lang: In Canada, revenue was flat year over year as net market share gains with new and existing clients for appraisal services were offset by lower market volumes and modestly lower insurance inspection revenues.
Brian Lang: Canadian net revenue margins were very strong at 18.9% and net revenue was up 5% from fiscal 2023.
Brian Lang: The Canadian segment generated adjusted EBITDA of $4.1 million, down from $4.2 million in fiscal 2023.
Brian Lang: With that, I'll hand it over to Rodrigo to take a look at the fourth quarter. Rodrigo.
Thank you, Brian, and good morning, everyone.
Rodrigo Pinto: U.S. mortgage market conditions showed some variability during the fourth quarter, and we saw several weeks of rate swings, which translated into variable transaction volumes throughout the quarter.
Speaker Change: As Brian discussed, we continue to believe that we have a large and expanding long-term opportunity ahead of us, and so we remain focused on the things we can control, including continuing to exercise discipline when it comes to our expenses, the timing of investment decisions, and how we scale based on volumes.
Speaker Change: We'll do what's necessary to grow our client base and our market share with our clients, managing our operating efficiency to drive margin expansion while maintaining a strong balance sheet.
Speaker Change: Turning to our fourth quarter financial performance, I'll start with our U.S. appraisal segment, where we recorded revenues of $33.8 million, up 8% from the same period last year.
Speaker Change: Revenues from purchase and refinance mortgage originations increased principally due to market share gains with existing and new clients and higher addressable mortgage origination volume for refinance transactions.
Speaker Change: Home equity revenues were up 9% year over year and accounted for 27% of the segment's revenue because of solid market share growth with our clients.
Speaker Change: U.S. appraisal net revenue was $9 million for the fourth quarter, up from $8.6 million in Q4'23, and net revenue margins decreased by 80 basis points, mostly due to distribution of transactions volume as it relates to geographies, clients, and product mix.
Speaker Change: We posted net revenue margins of 26.7% in Q4'24, which is well within our target operating model range.
Speaker Change: Fourth quarter U.S. appraisal operating expenses increased 7% year-over-year to $4.9 million.
Speaker Change: We posted U.S. appraisal adjusted EBITDA of $4.1 million, up 4% from the fourth quarter of fiscal 2023, and we posted adjusted EBITDA margins of 45.2% from the 46% we posted in the fourth quarter last year as the increasing net revenue was offset by higher operating expenses.
Speaker Change: Turning to our U.S. title segment, fourth quarter revenues increased 4% year-over-year to $2.4 million.
and Refinance Origination Revenues were up 29%.
due to market share gains with existing and new clients
Speaker Change: U.S. title net revenue was $1.2 million, up 15% from the fourth quarter last year, and net revenue margins increased to 49.8% from 45% due to higher refinance origination volumes.
Speaker Change: U.S. title operating expenses were up 6% year-over-year, and we recorded an adjusted EBITDA loss of $1.6 million for the U.S. title segment in line with our performance in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2023.
Speaker Change: Looking at our U.S. title segment performance on a sequential basis, fourth quarter net revenue increased 30% from Q3 2024 on stronger refinance market volumes and market share increases with our clients.
Speaker Change: This growth in net revenue coupled with our operating leverage and disciplined cost management allowed us to convert 100% of the increase to adjusted EBITDA.
Speaker Change: In Canada, fourth quarter revenues increased 8% year-over-year to $9.4 million due to higher market volumes and net market share gains with new and existing clients for appraisal services.
Insurance inspection revenues were relatively flat.
Speaker Change: Net revenue was up 14% to 1.8 million with 100 basis points increasing net revenue margins in the fourth quarter as we continue to leverage our platform.
Speaker Change: Canadian adjusted EBITDA was $1.2 million, up from $1.1 million in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2023.
Speaker Change: In total, fourth quarter consolidated revenue and net revenue were up 8% year-over-year to $45.6 million and $12 million, respectively, from improvements in all three segments. And we've recorded consolidated adjusted EBITDA of $0.6 million in line with our results in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2023.
Speaker Change: We ended the year with a very strong balance sheet with no debt and cash of $49.1 million at September 30, 2024. Our cash position increase in the fourth quarter was mainly due to the timing of collections.
With that, I'll turn back over to Brian. Brian?
Brian Lang: Thanks, Rodrigo. Real Matters delivered strong financial performance in fiscal 2024.
Brian Lang: Net revenues were up in all three segments. We continued to leverage our network to improve year-over-year net revenue margins in all three segments. We launched 16 new clients and four new channels, and we continued to drive market share increases with our clients in all three segments.
Brian Lang: Our business delivered positive, consolidated, adjusted EBITDA in one of the most challenging market environments on record.
Brian Lang: Heading into fiscal 2025 we are optimistic about the potential for growth as pent-up demand continues to build and the pool of potential future refinance candidates increases.
Brian Lang: These tailwinds, coupled with our market leadership and appraisal, and the significant potential for expanding our U.S. title business, position us well for growth.
Brian Lang: As we drive more transaction volumes on our platform, we expect to expand our mergings and profitability in line with our long-term operating model.
Brian Lang: Our team remains focused on increasing market share with our existing clients by optimizing scorecard performance and pursuing new client relationships, especially in US title.
Brian Lang: Our business was built to thrive in the peaks and to withstand valleys of the cyclical mortgage market and we have been successful in growing the business through a number of these cycles since the company was founded 20 years ago and we intend to do it again.
This October, the company celebrated its 20th anniversary.
Brian Lang: Reflecting on our history, two key elements have been foundational to our success as an organization.
Brian Lang: The first is our culture and the strength of our people. Their passion to win and ability to think big about our objectives is what has allowed us to innovate and build for the long term.
Brian Lang: To all our team members, I'd like to express our sincere gratitude for your ongoing commitment to the company.
Brian Lang: By extension, we also thank the field professionals on our network for their extraordinary contributions.
Brian Lang: The second is rooted in our vision, which is to empower incredibly smart decisions through technology.
Brian Lang: It's been a rallying cry since Jason Smith founded the company back in 2004 and has helped guide our strategy and how we think about growing the business ever since.
Speaker Change: On that note, I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge Jason for his unwavering commitment to this company over the last 20 years.
Speaker Change: As we announced this morning, he will be retiring from the Real Matters Board of Directors at our upcoming AGM.
Speaker Change: On behalf of the board, we would like to thank Jason for his invaluable contributions and leadership.
Speaker Change: It's been a privilege for me and our team to work alongside such an incredible individual. His energy and passion for the business is second to none, and we look forward to carrying on his legacy as we look forward to the next 20 years.
Speaker Change: With that, Operator, we'd like to open it up for questions now.
Speaker Change: Thank you, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, if you would like to ask a question, please press star followed by one on your touch-tone phone.
Speaker Change: You will then hear a three-tone prompt acknowledging your request. And if you would like to withdraw from the question queue, please press star followed by 2. And if using a speakerphone, you will need to lift the handset before pressing any keys. Please go ahead and press star 1 now if you have any questions.
Speaker Change: First question will be from Gavin Fairweather at Cormark Securities. Please go ahead.
Speaker Change: Hi there, this is Graham Smith on for Gavin. So you've talked a lot about the dynamic where you're gaining market share with your T1s.
Speaker Change: and those T1s have kind of been backing out of originations given the difficult market environment. Can you maybe talk about if you're seeing any early indications of those T1s, you know, re-entering or starting to re-engage given that we're expecting a bit of an upturn in C25 and in originations volumes?
Speaker Change: Thanks Graham, appreciated that. And just for the broader group, you're referencing our Tier 1 customers and I think you're mostly talking about
the appraisal business.
Speaker Change: But the Tier 1s, so as we've talked about in the past, we've really focused the business around the Tier 1s for a host of reasons. Number one, they're very performance focused, which of course is how we've built the business.
and so
because of the scorecard management that they have.
Speaker Change: They've definitely been a way in which we can continue to deliver and drive market share growth with them. So we've continued to see that, Graham, our market share growth with them. Another good year. We announced sort of three of the top appraisal customers that we've moved share with, as well as, of course, our Tier 1. We moved share with our, sorry, with Title. We moved share with our Tier 1 on Title.
Speaker Change: So it's been a good year on moving market share with our Tier 1s.
Speaker Change: I think your question refers to how they're doing in the market.
Speaker Change: And so I think we're definitely starting to see the winds move from what have been headwinds for them from a market share standpoint to the market, to tailwinds, and I think there's a host of reasons for that.
Speaker Change: One of the biggest reasons is, frankly, it's been difficult for some of the Tier 1s to make much money on sort of a per-mortgage basis over the last couple of years.
Speaker Change: They have now crossed back into positive territory and they are now making money on the incremental mortgages that are coming in. So that's a big significant change.
for the Tier 1s.
Speaker Change: And that was that was very reiterated to me just recently because we had the the big Mortgage Bankers Association conference
Speaker Change: last month, and clearly they are now starting to ready themselves.
Speaker Change: to reinvest, start looking at marketing, making sure that they're getting their operations set up.
Speaker Change: for what they expect will be some movement in the market in 2025. So, I mean, I think our view would be that we're incredibly well-positioned with the Tier 1s and they are now starting to better position themselves to start taking some market share back in 2025.
Speaker Change: That's really helpful, thanks so much. Just one more. Can you just give a bit more colour on the profile of the Tier 2 that you added to title this quarter? And then maybe if you could just talk about how the T2 pipeline is progressing.
Sure, so.
This quarter we did add Tier 2 to the mix.
One of the benefits of this movement of
Mortgage profitability coming back into play for the Tier 1s.
Speaker Change: is that that's also finding its way down into the tier twos and some of the tier threes so
Speaker Change: What has been a reasonably challenging pipeline for us, it's been a bit of a headwind over the last little while with volumes low.
That has definitely started unlocking some opportunity for us.
Speaker Change: as well as the Tier 1 RFP that we've talked about in the past that's in play and we're feeling very confident about getting an answer on that RFP this quarter.
and looking forward to some volume in 2025 calendar.
The Tier 2s have also started to unlock.
Speaker Change: As mentioned, we've launched a Tier 2. We've also had a couple of RFPs come in in the last six weeks with some of the Tier 2s.
Speaker Change: So, good news for us, with profitability comes the opportunity for that pipeline to unfreeze and for tier twos to start looking for partners as they see this expected refi pool start becoming available to them.
That's great, thanks, and I'll pass the line.
Speaker Change: Thank you. Next question will be from Stephen McKelson at BMO. Please go ahead, Stephen.
I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry
Stephen McKelson: Hi, thanks for taking my question. So it's been a couple years of streamlining your operations.
Stephen McKelson: With this prospective uptick in volume over the next year, how should we think about any investments that you might need to make to to handle this?
Speaker Change: net revenue to adjusted EBITDA conversion. You saw an appraisal on the 100% on title. I think what you're seeing there is the capacity that we've talked about having on both sides of those businesses.
Speaker Change: So the 3-4 times volume on title and the 30% incremental capacity on appraisal, again, in preparation for what we believe will be some increases in volume.
in the not-too-distant future.
Speaker Change: That's I think there's there's a you're seeing a lot of those Margin benefits already flowing through with very little
Speaker Change: upside, frankly, right now on volume. But I think as that volume ramp starts coming in in 2025, I think you're going to see more of that. And the only time we need to do much around the cost base on the operations of the business will be when we start seeing that type of incremental volume.
Speaker Change: where we'd need to invest beyond that. But there will be some investment in 2025 on the tech side of our business.
Speaker Change: We've held out through some of the tough market conditions over the last couple of years with some investments in tech.
Speaker Change: And so, both from sort of an industry standpoint, as well as getting our performance continually improved and distancing ourselves from the other competitors.
Speaker Change: We believe right now is the time to make a little bit of investment in that. So you will see a couple million dollars in tech investment in 2025.
Speaker Change: Okay, and had you already started that investment? It does look like corporate overhead did
go up a little bit this quarter.
Speaker Change: Great, why don't I pass it over to Rodrigo right here. Yeah, yes, Stephen, I would say we started what we call designing and planning parts of some of those enhancement projects in tech. So, yes, it is
Speaker Change: It started already, but we'll get to those numbers that Brian just shared with you throughout the year, fiscal 2025.
Speaker Change: And Stephen, just for clarity, the tech investments are for tech resources, right? We have a spectacular platform. So the platform, and I think we've shared with all of you, we're in the cloud now. So technically, from a platform standpoint, we're in incredibly good shape. This is investing in some tech pool resources, as Rodrigo said, right now in the design phase, and then of course in the execution phase in the back half of the year.
Speaker Change: No, no, good to hear. And just to dig in a little bit more on your customer or your clients.
Speaker Change: Expecting to ramp up volumes in fiscal 25. I mean, we've had a bit of whiplash with with rates over the last couple months
Speaker Change: Do you get the sense from them that any volume gains they might get are contingent on rates going down a substantial amount, or if rates kind of hang out where they are, will they still be investing for growth?
Speaker Change: Yeah, I would say, Stephen, it's been less around exactly where the rate is right now. I think, like us, they've been focused on this refinance pool that's been building. And I think you've got to remember that it's not the absolute rate that's really important here. It's the relative change in rates.
Speaker Change: So, right now, these past few weeks, we're sitting pretty close to 7% at the 30 years.
Speaker Change: You only need to see a 50 to 75 basis point change in there. So we're now in the 625 to 650 range.
Speaker Change: where it makes sense to refinance. So I think they're looking at that and seeing that pool and therefore it doesn't take much change in the rate.
Speaker Change: for there to be increases in volume and frankly we saw that in September. September, if you remember, we actually got down under six percent.
Speaker Change: for a couple weeks and the MBA application volumes went up and there's a fair bit of expectation of things moving.
Speaker Change: And then the rates, of course, went up again. So I think there is quite a bit of sensitivity right now around that rate, and as I say, it's the relative change in rate.
Speaker Change: As you probably know, Americans are incredibly focused on their rates.
Stephen McKelson: And also I think, Steve, it's important to remember, especially on the refinance side, currently almost 90% of the refinances that are going on are cash-out refinances, right? So these are people that are going through big life decisions.
Stephen McKelson: They're getting married, they're dealing with funerals, they're dealing with, you know, university, big things going on in people's lives. And so our view is that's not going to change, and I don't think any of the lenders think that's going to change. So we've got a baseline of volume that's there, and I think their view is it's only going to build on top of that.
Speaker Change: with some relative changes in rates in 2025. So I think that's the big driver, I think, Stephen.
All right. Thanks for the color. I'll pass the line.
Speaker Change: Thank you. Next question will be from Martin Toner at ATB Capital Markets. Please go ahead Martin. Thank you very much. Good morning. Can you guys talk a little bit about
Your expectations for further improvement in net revenue in 2025?
Rodrigo Pinto: Sure, so why don't I pass that one over to Rodrigo. Sure, sure. And Martin, the reality is...
Rodrigo Pinto: Again, net revenue margins will fluctuate based on distribution of transactions and that held true especially in a low
Rodrigo Pinto: volume market environment, but again, our expectation for next year is that our net revenue margins will stay within the target operating model range, that is especially for US appraisal, 26 to 28 percent.
Rodrigo Pinto: On the title side, again, as you saw this quarter, we saw the highest net revenue margin for the title segment over the last 24 months, or eight quarters.
Rodrigo Pinto: There's a dependency in volumes there, but again, our goal is to get to our target operating model.
Okay, thanks and...
What are your expectations for mortgage volumes? Refi and purchase?
Rodrigo Pinto: Like, let's say grapes kind of bounce around the midpoint between like 6 and where they peak at 8. Like, let's say we kick around...
Rodrigo Pinto: somewhere in the middle of that fairly large range next year. What do you think is possible from a volume perspective?
Speaker Change: Yeah, I mean, Martin, why don't we start with, I just think, the context of...
Speaker Change: We have been in and we have a slight up on the lowest volumes in the last 30 plus years, right? So we've got to start there. We then layer in the title commentary I just gave you around cash out being the vast majority of the transactions that are in there.
Speaker Change: And if we look forward, if you take a look at the industry, folks, you're going to see some folks think positivity, some folks think a little bit negativity. So it sort of depends, as you say, an awful lot.
of what ends up happening in the rate environment.
Speaker Change: But we're coming off of the lowest base, as I say, in the last 30 plus years.
Speaker Change: So I think in our view, we've got a bit of a seasonality kick, as you know, in our Q1 and Q2. So I think there'll be a little bit of seasonality in there. But I think especially when we look out to Q3 and Q4, we think there's a real upside opportunity. I think our lenders see a real upside opportunity.
Speaker Change: refly pool and I think the view is that that's going to kick in because there's going to be some movement in in the relative change in rates.
Speaker Change: And as you know, Martin, we stay totally focused on the stuff we can control, which hopefully you saw from our 2024 results, driving the margins, winning the market share. That's the focus.
Speaker Change: Absolutely. Thanks so much for that, Brian. So you talked a little bit about this already. We're just going to kind of...
Speaker Change: Yeah, so I again I'm going to reflect back just a just back to that September comment that I made
Speaker Change: when we talked about the fact that the rate came down and we got into the under six Martin. So if you actually went down and did a little bit of analysis there you'd see the tier ones went in very competitively during that time.
So
Speaker Change: Three of the Tier 1s were down in the 5.5 range.
Speaker Change: volume that's coming in. They are coming out of a couple of years where they were having negative growth from a revenue standpoint as new volume came in.
Speaker Change: And so, as I mentioned, it's sort of clearly out in the market now that that change has occurred where they've gone from negative territory and they're now making money on mortgages again.
Speaker Change: that they are now in a position, profitability ahead of them, they see a big refi pool. They're definitely focused on bringing back some of that market share that they may have given.
Speaker Change: over the last couple of years. So again, I feel pretty bold in saying that I think the tier ones are gonna step back in and I would not be surprised in 2025 to see them taking some market share.
Thank you.
Speaker Change: Awesome, thank you. Last one for me. Are you as strong on scorecards in title as you are in appraisal? And maybe if there's a difference can you kind of talk a little bit about like the relative value proposition of each solution?
Pet.
Speaker Change: Yeah, I know I can firmly say since I saw the most recent scorecard on title that we're number one on title, Martin, so good news. We continue to be at the top of the scorecard.
Speaker Change: on the tier one side. And frankly, there's very little difference in the scorecards beyond the fact that some of the content's a little bit different, Martin. The way they run their scorecarding process, I think I've mentioned in the past, it's under the same vendor management team. So, you know, it's a very diligent process. It's by product, by region, by you name it. And it's the same across both sides of the business.
Speaker Change: The only challenge in such a low environment as we have now is it's harder for us to distance ourselves as we did when there was a lot more volume.
Speaker Change: and as we expect there will be once we see volume come back up. So, the difference between 1st and 5th or 6th, depending on how many vendors they have, is a little tighter right now than it would be when we get more volume. But we continue to be number one on scorecards on both sides of the fence, appraisal and title.
Speaker Change: Do you have any sense for how much capacity some of the tier one lenders have given that they've consolidated their vendor relationships during this downturn?
Speaker Change: I mean, the question is starting getting to, like, what's their, you know, what's their need to add new ones as we ramp up volume shift.
Speaker Change: Well, yeah, I think it sort of comes back a little bit to Martin. They've now brought down their cost to such a level where they're now profitable again. So they've now got themselves into a much sort of smaller shell than they would have been a couple of years ago. And so they have told, and again, this is reiterating what I heard a few weeks ago, they've reiterated the first question to me was, what happens when volumes double? How fast can you start taking on volume?
Speaker Change: So I think they are now in a position where they have less capacity and so as the market begins to build again They are definitely looking to outsource and that's why I think we're seeing some of the tier twos frankly Especially on the title side start opening up RFPs
Speaker Change: is exactly that. They're starting to look towards the refi pool, the refi opportunity, and they want to start looking for the partners that are going to help them through what I think will be a good refi build over the next couple years.
Speaker Change: Well, let's hope they have that good problem sometime soon. That's it for me. Yeah. Thanks Martin. Thank you Martin.
Speaker Change: Hi, good morning. Maybe just some refresh around the tier one title pipeline. I think you had two in process earlier in the call. I think you said maybe one might be awarded to the RRP presses might close or finish before the end of this calendar year or was that fiscal year?
and maybe you can just give us a sense of...
Speaker Change: What that might do to the financial model if you do win a Tier 1.
Speaker Change: an additional Tier 1, because I look at the current quarter and you know, OPEX is flat against revenue growth in title, and so, I mean, if you add a significant customer, you added a significant of this quarter with the Tier 2, I believe. How should we think about that?
Speaker Change: That's a great question and thanks for that, Rob. So, on the Tier 1 side, Title Tier 1, the game plan has been throughout the year to close that RFP by the end of the calendar year.
And so the RFP process has been completed,
Speaker Change: the participants know the outcome. So, good news, the RFP is closed. Everything is done that needs to be done. We should be notified in the next two to three weeks, but by the end of this calendar year.
Speaker Change: So that's on the fairly significant big Tier 1. The other Tier 1 is still in play, Rob, as I've talked about. It's been a little less structured than the first Tier 1 I just talked about, but our view is that we should be notified next quarter, so in RQ2, as to where we stand on that other Tier 1 RFP.
Speaker Change: Beyond that, as I mentioned, the good news is we landed a Tier 2. We've also now started RFP processes with a couple of other Tier 2s.
Speaker Change: And so, our view is, good news, that pipeline is definitely starting to open.
Rodrigo Pinto: As far as how it impacts our results, I'm going to pass that over to Rodrigo and he can talk a little bit about how we've built that into our model for 2025. Sure, sure. So Rob, again, the...
Rodrigo Pinto: The first tier one that Brian mentioned, like just thinking of the size of the financial institution itself.
Rodrigo Pinto: At full steam, same market share, it could double the volumes that we are seeing title. They are about the same size, large financial institution in the United States. So at full steam, double the volume of transactions, which would translate to doubling the revenue. However, for fiscal 2025, there's a ramp-up period. So we won't see...
Rodrigo Pinto: you know, that full capacity in this upcoming fiscal year. Our view is hopefully towards the end of the fiscal year we'll be there, but at the beginning of the year, of course, there's a ramp-up period. I would say in fiscal 26, yes, I would feel confident to say it should double our volumes without considering any changes in the market.
Okay, and
Speaker Change: If the Tier 1 award that you're hoping to learn about soon, is that likely to be awarded across multiple vendors, or are you expecting it to be an exclusive award? Are they adding to a current group of providers, or is it a re-assessment of the split amongst existing vendors adding new vendors? Maybe just take a sense of that.
tonight.
Speaker Change: The interest in going through these RFPs is there's actually a fair bit of complexity around these RFPs. You're actually, you know, working through states, working through products. So there's a fair bit of complexity to it.
Speaker Change: That being said, as I mentioned, we were in this finalist group of less than a dozen other players, and in our view they will most likely have something like half a dozen.
Speaker Change: that's sort of been their their past behavior and so so I assume that's sort of where we'll land on being part of that that type of group and of course our our goal internally is to drive our market share up of course as quickly as we can perform the way we are performing now with the other tier one be top of the scorecard.
Rodrigo Pinto: And frankly, get ourselves to the same market share that we have on the appraisal side of the house with the same tier one. So that's kind of the long-term goal. And why don't I pass it to Rodrigo for other comments? No, no, no. That's fair. I just want to add, Rob, because Martin had a similar question. What do we learn over the years? It's not about capacity.
There's always room to displace low performers.
Speaker Change: So as long as we perform well, it's not related to the capacity, how much they'll give. If you are a high performer, top-up scorecard, you should get...
Speaker Change: more market share. That's why our strategy was, you know, let's go to tier ones, because they are a performance-based allocation of volumes there.
Speaker Change: Okay, and then maybe just a little one, the Tier 2 you won, does any of that lead into Q1 or does most of that benefit in Q4? I'm just trying to think of the puts and takes around the seasonality in Q1.
Speaker Change: Yeah, so the Tier 2 that we've now brought on, that again, Rob, is a build, right? So you have to build over time. Of course, we've built in...
Speaker Change: to our model that we will have revenue coming in by the start of next quarter and we should see that of course through the through the year.
Speaker Change: And then the rest of the Tier 2s, the RFP pipeline, we've accounted for some of that, but of course it's in the second half of the year. So, again, our view would be we're gonna have some seasonality right now. That seasonality, that Q3, Q4, we should see on the title side some decent incremental volume coming from both Tier 1 and new Tier 2s.
But of course, rate-dependent, of course, well, rate-dependent, of course.
Of course.
Speaker Change: Last question, I'll pass the line. Just, I mean, a lot of changes in the U.S. political environment. I'm sure you're looking at the appointments and looking at some of the things that could pop out of it, and possible questions to answer, but if you just give us a sense of what you're seeing as it relates to your business, what's going on in the U.S., maybe some things for investors to think about, and then I'll pass the line.
I'm going to be a little bit more nervous.
Speaker Change: Great, I mean I think it's still early days Rob frankly and so I think of course we're keeping an eye on what's going on in the U.S. but I think it's really too early to make too much commentary around around what we think. I mean the one good news story is
Speaker Change: definitely seems to be quite supportive of the banks in the U.S. and taking down regulation, having less regulation. So that, I think, is probably a good tailwind for us as we look to the future. And I think that will help sort of fuel some of those Tier 1s back to our earlier commentary around continuing to invest and grow and gain market share.
Speaker Change: Okay, save that one for the next quarter to ask you, and pass the line.
Speaker Change: Thank you. Once again, as a reminder, ladies and gentlemen, if you do have any questions, please press star followed by 1 on your touchtone phone.
Speaker Change: Next question will be from Richard C. at National Bank. Please go ahead, Richard.
Hi, good morning. This is Mike Stevens on for Rich.
Speaker Change: I wanted to you talked a lot about you know capacity in terms of the higher volumes like is that how much of a function of that is on the tier ones and your lending partners versus your own capacity?
Speaker Change: and kind of to follow up on that. So if you start to see the market turning, volumes trending higher, if you do need to add to your OPEX, how far in advance do you need to add that capacity to meet that demand? And what areas would you be looking to add?
Speaker Change: Great question. So I think when we're talking about capacity, the Tier 1s have definitely brought their capacity down in line with the current market, which is why you're seeing positive revenue that they're now able to to drive on their mortgage business. So they have definitely brought their cost base down.
Speaker Change: As you probably are aware, it's very difficult for them to start building capacity. They have started talking about putting some more capacity in, but as volume starts coming in, in this type of environment, usually what they do is look to the vendors to start taking on a significant portion of that incoming volume.
Speaker Change: I think, you know, we're incredibly well poised because of our level of market share with all of the Tier 1s.
Speaker Change: that they will outsource a good portion of incoming volume and that we will be the recipients of that.
Speaker Change: And so back to our capacity on title, we can take three to four times the volume that any of them are giving us today without having to invest in our operations OPEX, right? And on appraisal that number looks more like 30%. So
Speaker Change: Depending on how much volume comes in, I think we're really well set up to be able to, as we did this past quarter, drive a considerable amount of the net revenue right down to adjusted EBITDA.
Rodrigo Pinto: And with that, why don't I pass it over to Rodrigo to talk a little bit around the financial side of that. Yeah. So, Mike, again, if we see volumes coming our way from market share gains, new clients are recovering the markets.
Rodrigo Pinto: to align, you know, when we need to add those costs to attend the new revenue coming our way. We work very closely with our clients to ensure that we can make those decisions at the right time.
Speaker Change: Okay, perfect. That's super helpful. And maybe that ties in well then with, you know, you're in a good cash position in terms of capital allocation. Is it kind of more about, you know, waiting to be agile in case the market turns? Or are there any other opportunities?
be it inorganic that you could look at going forward.
Speaker Change: Another good question. So, you know, I think we keep an eye on capital allocation strategy and sort of long-term view on where we want to allocate.
Speaker Change: any of our investments. As you've heard, in the very short term some of our investments are definitely going into making sure that we continue to drive incredible performance and get prepared from a tech standpoint for what we think will be
Speaker Change: an increase in the volumes coming in, but longer term, we keep an eye on M&A opportunities.
future.
Speaker Change: keeping an eye on the opportunity, the refly opportunity, and delivering against our sort of total operating model expectations.
For more information visit www.FEMA.gov
Okay, perfect. Appreciate the insights.
Speaker Change: Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes our question and answer period, as well as our conference call for today. We would like to thank you for taking the time to attend and ask that you please disconnect your lines.
Have a good day.
Thank you. Thank you.