Back to News
Market Impact: 0.3

Newmont Stock Is Interesting, but Here's What I'd Buy Instead​

Commodities & Raw MaterialsCompany FundamentalsCorporate EarningsBanking & LiquidityInvestor Sentiment & PositioningAnalyst Insights
Newmont Stock Is Interesting, but Here's What I'd Buy Instead​

Gold has more than doubled since 2021 to about $4,647/oz, driving strong returns across the sector: Newmont (NEM) trades around $110 and has outperformed gold over the past 12 months (NEM +182% vs gold +76%), with a net income margin of 33%, three-year revenue CAGR of 21%, debt of $5.65B and cash of $5.97B. By contrast Wheaton Precious Metals (WPM), a streaming company, returned ~132% over 12 months, reports a 54.7% net income margin, three-year revenue CAGR of 18.2%, cash reserves of $1.16B against only $7.9M of debt, and is presented as a lower-capital, higher-profitability way to gain gold exposure versus owning mining operators.

Analysis

Market structure: Streaming companies (WPM) and other low-capex royalty/streaming players are the primary beneficiaries as gold price appreciation transfers economic value to claimants of produced ounces rather than to operators; high-cost/junior miners and leveraged producers (some NEM peers) are the losers if capex and permitting remain constrained. The competitive dynamic shifts pricing power toward financiers/streamers who lock in fixed low purchase prices while capturing upside; expect M&A and more streaming deals over 6–24 months, compressing future miner margins. Supply/demand: constrained new mine supply (multi-year lead times) vs. continued central bank + retail ETF demand supports a sustained higher price floor; marginal supply elasticity is low, so incremental demand shocks lift price materially. Cross-asset: sustained gold strength likely coincides with falling real yields, weaker USD (−2–5%) and higher commodity volatility; safe-haven flows can depress risk assets and push 2s–10s Treasury yields down 10–40bps in risk-off spikes.

Risk assessment: Tail risks include a rapid USD rally/real yield spike (USD index +5% or real yields +100bps within 60 days) that could knock gold −15–25% and crush streaming re-rates, or sovereign/contractual clampdowns on streaming terms in producer jurisdictions. Immediate (days) risk = volatility from macro prints; short-term (weeks–months) = positioning-driven reversals and quarterly production misses; long-term (years) = structural supply changes or technological shifts in extraction/recycling. Hidden dependencies: WPM’s economics rely on counterparty production schedules and commodity mix (copper/zinc byproduct silver/gold content); renegotiation or mine underperformance is a second-order value destroyer. Catalysts: Fed hikes/dovish pivots, Q1 mine reports (next 30–90 days), any large streaming deal announcements.

More News