Amazon is selling used cars now, but Cars Commerce and CarGurus aren’t worried

The inaugural Automotive News Auto Industry Confidence Index reports that dealership executives hold a negative outlook for the automotive industry during the second half of 2025. This indicates a concerning sentiment from a key sector regarding future market conditions.

Analysis

The inaugural Automotive News Auto Industry Confidence Index indicates a negative outlook among dealership executives for the second half of 2025. This sentiment is a significant leading indicator for the broader automotive sector, as dealership principals have frontline visibility into consumer demand, inventory flow, and financing conditions. The provided sentiment score of -0.45 (moderately negative) quantifies this pessimistic view, suggesting that key retail stakeholders anticipate material headwinds. While the specific drivers for this sentiment are not provided, the signal itself warrants attention as it points to potential future pressure on vehicle sales, margins, or overall industry health. As this is the first iteration of the index, it establishes a new, albeit bearish, baseline for tracking industry confidence without historical context for comparison.

Key Decisions for Investors

• Investors with exposure to the automotive sector should consider this negative forward-looking sentiment from a key industry group as a potential risk factor for H2 2025 and beyond.
• It is advisable to monitor subsequent releases of this new index to establish a trend and gauge whether the pessimistic outlook persists, worsens, or improves over time.
• Look for corroborating or conflicting data points in upcoming earnings reports and guidance from auto manufacturers, suppliers, and lenders to validate the concerns highlighted by dealership executives.