What Goes Into a Private Credit Fund’s Level 3 Valuation?
Ares Capital’s September 2026 filing connects $28.639 billion of Level 3 investments with the yields, discount rates and multiples used to value them.
In this article
Ares Capital reported $28.639 billion of Level 3 investments at September 30, 2026. That was 98.04% of its $29.213 billion investment portfolio. For an allocator reviewing how a private credit manager prices assets, the percentage is only a starting point. Ares used a market-yield assumption for $16.599 billion of first-lien loans and a discount-rate assumption for $1.153 billion of subordinated certificates. Those marks call for different questions even though they occupy the same accounting level. Ares Capital third-quarter filing, Note 8, printed pages 201–203
Reconcile the hierarchy to investments on the balance sheet
Ares Capital is a publicly listed business development company. Its own share price is observable. Many of its underlying loans lack quoted prices for identical instruments in active markets. The filing uses Level 1 for accessible active-market quotes on identical items, Level 2 for valuations using observable inputs, and Level 3 where a significant input is unobservable. The classification describes the evidence used for a mark. It does not supply a default probability, an exit timetable or an automatic discount to carrying value.
| Investments on September 30, 2026 | Fair value, USD millions |
|---|---|
| Level 1 | 42 |
| Level 2 | 441 |
| Level 3 | 28,639 |
| Investments inside the three levels | 29,122 |
| Investments measured using the NAV practical expedient | 91 |
| Total investments | 29,213 |
Dividing $28.639 billion by the $29.122 billion inside the hierarchy gives 98.34%. Using all investments gives 98.04%. Both fractions are reproducible. The latter answers how much of the entire investment portfolio has a Level 3 mark. The $91 million recorded using net asset value remains visible in the reconciliation. Keep unfunded commitments and derivatives in their own lines when using the investment total as the denominator. Ares fair-value hierarchy and reconciliation, printed page 202
Ask for the assumption that could move the mark
The next page connects instrument groups to the unobservable inputs. The $16.599 billion first-lien loan group used a weighted-average market yield of 10.3%, with assumptions from 5.3% to 26.3%. The $1.019 billion second-lien group used 16.0%, ranging from 8.2% to 31.4%. Ares weights those inputs by relative fair value. The observed difference between the two averages is 5.7 percentage points. The ranges overlap, and the filing does not present the groups as matched loans to the same borrowers.
For a first-lien loan, ask what comparable financing and borrower changes support the selected market yield. The contractual coupon tells the analyst what the borrower owes. The assumed market yield helps determine what a buyer would pay for those expected payments on the measurement date. The filing describes comparing terms, maturity and credit risk. Holding expected cash flows fixed, a higher required yield lowers their present value. The size of the change still depends on when cash will be received.
Ares used discounted cash flow for the $1.153 billion of subordinated certificates, with a 9.4% to 12.8% discount-rate range and an 11.3% weighted average. Here the next question is which cash flows reach that instrument after senior claims. A portfolio-wide average loan yield cannot answer it. The quarterly filing identifies the technique and input range, but it does not publish a security-level cash-flow model for each position. Valuation methods and significant inputs, printed pages 201–203
Follow a specific mark back to its owner
An independent valuation range and the final accounting mark can come from different parties. Ares describes preliminary work by its investment professionals and valuation team. Where an independent provider reviews a position, it supplies a range. The valuation designee's committee determines the value and considers that input. The SEC's fund valuation framework provides for board oversight when a board appoints a valuation designee. Ares's quarterly process, Note 2, printed page 170 · SEC guide to fair-value determinations
For teams that repeat this work across managers, we recommend AllMind Data Rooms to compare the valuation policy, financial statements and any pricing memo the manager has shared. Link the policy clause to the instrument, input and date. If only the public filing is available, the allocator can document how much value relies on judgment and which assumptions to challenge. A conclusion about a particular mark requires that position's evidence. Our private credit income guide addresses a separate check on whether reported income has turned into cash.