How to Compare Retail Sales Across 52- and 53-Week Years

Target’s extra week changes the sign of sales growth. Costco’s results show why correcting the calendar still leaves a separate same-store sales question.

In this article

Target’s net sales fell 0.8% in fiscal 2024. Remove the approximately $1.7 billion earned in the prior year’s extra week and net sales grew about 0.8%. Target also reported comparable sales growth of 0.1%. For an analyst updating the income statement, the first figure preserves the reported result. For a forecast of sales across the whole business over an equal number of weeks, the second is a better starting point. For demand at the retailer’s comparable stores and digital channels, use the third. Target’s fiscal 2024 results and definitions

Use the sales from the extra week when the retailer gives them

Target’s fiscal year ended February 1, 2025, after 52 weeks. The preceding year ended February 3, 2024, after 53. Take both net sales figures from the fiscal 2024 filing, where Target presented both years on the same revenue basis. Its new single line includes revenue previously displayed separately from merchandise sales. Target’s consolidated statements and fiscal-year note

Target fiscal 2024 calculationFY2024 net salesFY2023 comparison baseChange
Reported, 52 weeks versus 53$106,566m$107,412m−0.79%
Remove the disclosed extra week from FY2023$106,566mAbout $105,712mAbout +0.81%
Compare average sales per week$2,049m per week$2,027m per week+1.12%

The second row uses $107,412 million less Target’s rounded $1,700 million estimate. That left roughly $854 million more sales in the current 52 weeks. The third row divides each full-year total by its own week count before comparing the unrounded averages. An average FY2023 week was worth about $2.03 billion, roughly $327 million more than the extra week actually contributed on Target’s estimate. Using the average would overstate growth on the disclosed 52-week basis by about 0.31 percentage points. Retail weeks have different sales volumes. Target’s five-year summary, footnote (a)

The remaining difference between approximately 0.8% calendar-adjusted growth and 0.1% comparable sales belongs in the investment note. Target’s comparable measure covers merchandise sales and excludes stores open less than 13 months and stores that have closed. Its total also reflects new stores and non-merchandise revenues. A calendar correction alone leaves all of those in the total. Target’s discussion of comparable sales

Costco’s adjusted comparable sales answer a second question

Costco’s fiscal 2024 fourth quarter ended September 1, 2024. Its net sales rose from $77,430 million in a 17-week quarter to $78,185 million in a 16-week quarter. That gives 0.98% reported growth. Average sales per week grew 7.29%, calculated by dividing $78,185 million by 16 and $77,430 million by 17 before comparing the averages. This calculation includes the whole business and gives every week equal weight. Costco’s fiscal 2024 fourth-quarter release

Costco separately matched comparable locations and retail weeks. On that basis it reported 5.4% growth for the total company. After excluding changes in gasoline prices and foreign exchange, it reported 6.9%. The 1.5 percentage-point difference is the combined adjustment shown by the two columns. Assigning the entire difference to gasoline would require a separate breakdown. Applying an extra-week adjustment to the 5.4% figure would correct the calendar twice. Costco’s comparable sales table and footnote

For a peer comparison, keep the fiscal end date, week count, eligible-sales definition and any price or currency adjustment beside the growth rate. Target’s fiscal 2024 included the holiday season ending in early 2025. Costco’s fiscal 2024 ended months earlier. Putting their figures in a column headed “FY2024” cannot establish which retailer had stronger demand over the same calendar period.

If a retailer supplies only the annual totals and week counts, an analyst can still calculate a per-week change. Label it as an estimate of the average sales pace and leave the sales attributable to the extra week open. An AI-assisted model that labels this result “same-store sales” has produced the wrong answer for existing stores, even if every number links to the right release. Our guide to research tools for peer earnings covers how to carry that distinction into the next company’s forecast.